Our branches compete with each other in a monthly league table of sales and margin, and branch managers' bonuses depend partly on it. Last year, one branch on the edge of a city kept falling down the table while the town around it was building more houses than anywhere else in our region.
The regional director asked whether the branch was losing trade customers to a competitor. Finance had already modelled reducing its staff. Before anyone acted, an analyst on my team was asked to explain the decline and looked at the credit notes first.
The branch sits beside three large housing developments. Builders on those sites buy from whichever of our branches has the stock, often our big distribution branch thirty miles away. When they finish a phase, they bring the leftover blocks, plasterboard and insulation back to the branch nearest the site. Our trading system books every return against the branch that processes it.
So the branch was refunding goods that other branches had sold, and every refund came off its own sales and margin. In the year, it had taken back four hundred and thirty thousand pounds of goods sold elsewhere. The distribution branch kept the full value of those sales and had quietly enjoyed one of its best years for margin. Both branches' figures were accurate. They answered a question nobody had asked, which was where the paperwork was done.
Returns now have to be linked to the original invoice, which our counter staff find by scanning the delivery note or searching the customer's account. The refund reverses the sale at the branch that made it, and the branch that took the goods back receives a handling credit and the stock. Returns without an invoice still happen, and they are reported separately with the branch that accepted them, so the volume of them is visible rather than hidden in someone's sales.
The branch finished this year fourth in the league. Nothing changed there except the arithmetic.
Every record says where something happened. Not every record says whose it is. When figures are used to judge people, make sure you are counting the second.
– Serguey Shinder
Top comments (0)