DEV Community

Cover image for One Tile Left in Shut the Box: What Are Your Chances?
The Little Dice Club
The Little Dice Club

Posted on Originally published at shutthebox.cc

One Tile Left in Shut the Box: What Are Your Chances?

By The Little Dice Club

With one open tile numbered 1 through 6 and one fair six-sided die, your chance of closing it on the next roll is 1/6. With two dice, the answer depends on the tile number. Check which dice your rules require before using an odds table.

Key takeaways

  • A single open tile requires an exact matching total.
  • Under a forced one-die rule, each remaining low tile has the same next-roll chance.
  • These conditional endgame odds are not whole-game success rates.

State the rules and the event

This example uses addition-only moves, distinct open tiles, fair independent dice, and a round ending when a roll offers no legal move. The event being calculated is clearing the last tile on the next roll.

When only one tile remains, you cannot split it or combine it with a closed tile. If tile 5 is open, a target total of 4 is not playable. A failed roll ends the round under these assumptions; there is no unlimited retry.

The knowledge-base house rules describe a forced switch to one die when no tile above 6 remains. Physical sets may use a different trigger or allow a choice. Establish that rule first.

One die gives six equally likely outcomes

For a remaining tile from 1 through 6, exactly one face matches it. Each therefore has probability 1/6. Tile 1 is not harder to roll than tile 6 with a fair single die.

A remaining tile above 6 cannot be closed using one die. Under the forced-switch rule described above, high tiles instead keep two-dice play active.

Two dice give different totals different weights

Two fair independent six-sided dice have 36 equally likely ordered outcomes. The pair 2 then 5 and the pair 5 then 2 are different outcomes even though both total 7. Exact enumeration gives:

Last tile Matching outcomes Chance with two dice
1 0 0/36
2 1 1/36
3 2 2/36
4 3 3/36
5 4 4/36
6 5 5/36
7 6 6/36
8 5 5/36
9 4 4/36
10 3 3/36
11 2 2/36
12 1 1/36

This is a mathematical enumeration, not observed player data. The probability guide explains the underlying outcome count.

If your rules allow a choice

If one or two dice are both permitted with a single low tile remaining, one die gives the higher immediate clearing chance for every tile from 1 through 6. For tile 6, compare 1/6 with 5/36; for tile 1, two dice cannot produce the target at all.

This comparison is conditional on having exactly one tile left. It is not a general proof that one die is always better with several tiles open. Multiple open tiles create additional subset sums, changing the successful totals.

Keep the final score separate from the chance of zero

A last tile of 9 and a last tile of 7 have different two-dice clear probabilities. They also leave different scores on failure under sum scoring. Choosing an earlier move to maximize the chance of zero and choosing it to minimize expected remaining score are separate objectives.

Do not use the final-tile table to declare an earlier move optimal without considering all resulting positions. The 1, 2 and 3 endgame example shows how to follow more than one remaining move.

Record the state alongside the result

Write down the last tile, required dice, and scoring rule. A successful clear is one outcome; a failed attempt is another. Neither changes the fair-dice probabilities for the next independent round. Use the scoring guide to record the result under a consistent method.

Top comments (0)