How should the value of an employee be measured? That's honestly a really tough question. I do know of some ways that do not work. I am a software engineer team lead and here are some managing styles that don't work.
Butt In Seat
Not that long ago an employees value was measured by seeing them in person at their desk working away. Back when we all worked in the office I had a Sr. manager (two above me) who would walk around the office and pop his head into your room to have "small talk" about nothing important. If he did not see you in your room you would get a message from your manager to talk about your productivity. This kills trust.
When work went 100% remote the same thing happened with Slack. When your activity dot went from green to gray you could bet that you would get a message from this same manger about something random. If you didn't respond in 5 minutes you could expect a message from your direct manager about productivity.
First Responders
When an issue arises, being able to respond quickly is a good thing but as soon as its a measurement of ones value is when it becomes dangerous. Many times when an issue comes up people will respond blindly to it firing from the hip. This can cause damage and lead people down wrong paths. Taking a moment to think through the issue and do research before throwing out answers is much more beneficial. But guess what, you are late to the party and the "First Responder" credit has already been claimed. GG.
Number of Tasks Completed
In software development we track our work with tickets. We take a ticket that has acceptance criteria, work on it and then deliver it. Measuring the number of tickets an employee completes is good way of seeing their value but it does not paint the full story.
I had a co worker who was a high ticket completer. He would crunch out close to 25% more tickets than the next highest contributor. Management loved this employee. I mean why shouldn't they? He is getting shiz done! Well, taking a closer work at what was actually happening painted things very differently. Over half of the tickets he was completing was fixing bugs from previous work he had completed. Most of the production outages were due to a change he had made. What's interesting is that he was also the first one to respond to these issue making him look like a hero. Want to know how to be the best fire fighter? Be the first to the scene by creating the fire yourself.
Talk The Most In Meetings
I had a Coworker who quickly moved up in the ranks because he had a loud voice in a meeting. He would talk over anyone and interrupt who ever was talking if he had something on his mind. Unfortunately management saw this as a sign of strength and good leadership. What it did is caused others to not speak their mind. Who likes getting trampled? Especially in front of their peers!
Having a strong opinion can be a good thing but it needs to be shared with respect for others.
Thanks for taking the time to read this article. I hope to do a follow up article on things that I have seen that do work.
Top comments (0)