You're selling one subscription that covers a private Telegram channel and its discussion group. A buyer pays, joins, then turns off auto-renewal. To compare Nemiling and Tribute for that offer, follow the same three records: the buyer's receipt, the creator's payment record, and the buyer's membership in each chat.
Disclosure: This comparison uses public documentation. The numbers and timeline below are illustrative; I did not run live purchases.
At checkout: What does the buyer pay?
Suppose both offers list a seven-day subscription at RUB 100 (≈ $1.21). That gives you the same starting price, but you still need to check the final total before payment.
- Nemiling: When the creator connects a payment provider, payment goes through that provider to the creator's provider account. The provider sets processing and settlement terms. Nemiling's monthly tiers are based on turnover across the account. The free tier covers up to RUB 5,000 (≈ $60.42) in monthly eligible turnover; provider fees can still apply.
- Tribute: The fee guide lists a 10% creator fee, including processing. It also lists a separate, variable buyer fee, with exceptions such as payments via Telegram Wallet. The creator fee alone doesn't tell you the buyer's total. The creator sees proceeds in Tribute; the payout rules determine when the balance can be withdrawn. The guide lists RUB 3,000 (≈ $36.25) as the threshold for ruble payouts.
Compare like with like: verify that both services offer a comparable payment method for your buyer market and subscription. Telegram requires Stars for digital goods and services sold inside bots and Mini Apps. A card checkout and a Stars purchase aren't interchangeable for this cost comparison.
What the same sales volume can cost the creator
For illustration, assume Nemiling's Business plan at RUB 1,790 (≈ $21.63) per month, a hypothetical 2.5% card processing fee, and no other sales consuming the account's turnover allowance. Apply Tribute's published creator rate of 10% to the same subscription sales. These are modeled costs to the creator, excluding buyer fees, payout costs, conversion, refunds, and taxes.
| Monthly subscription sales | Nemiling plan + hypothetical processing | Tribute creator fee |
|---|---|---|
| RUB 20,000 (≈ $241.68) | RUB 2,290 (≈ $27.67) | RUB 2,000 (≈ $24.17) |
| RUB 40,000 (≈ $483.36) | RUB 2,790 (≈ $33.71) | RUB 4,000 (≈ $48.34) |
The lower-cost option flips between the two rows. If your provider quotes a different fee or your account qualifies for another tier, recalculate. The table also tells you nothing about how long it takes for the money to reach your bank account.
USD equivalents use the Bank of Russia's official rate for November 10, 2026: USD 1 = RUB 82.7536. They are for reference and are not checkout exchange rates.
After checkout: What happens when renewal is turned off?
First, confirm membership in both chats. Nemiling documents access tiers that can include a channel and a group. Tribute documents how to include a linked discussion group in a channel subscription. A successful charge doesn't show which chats the buyer joined. Check membership from a subscriber account without admin rights or access through another offer.
Then turn off renewal and read the paid-through time. On Nemiling, Stop Auto-Renewal is separate from disabling the subscription. On Tribute, subscribers use Cancel Subscription; Tribute says access continues until the paid period ends. Turning off renewal does not refund a charge that has already gone through.
For example, suppose the subscription screen shows access paid through November 17 at 12:00 UTC. Nemiling documents renewal attempts a day before expiry and at expiry on supported providers. To test cancellation before the next charge in that example, turn it off before November 16 at 12:00 UTC. Save the cancellation confirmation and the paid-through time shown after cancellation.
Finally, check both chats after expiry. Nemiling documents access removal when an unrenewed paid period ends. Tribute documents removal from a private channel after cancellation; check the linked group separately instead of assuming it was removed at the same time. Keep this test separate from a failed renewal: Tribute documents a seven-day retry period for failed payments, with removal after that period if payment still fails.
What I'd compare before launching
Record the final buyer total, the net proceeds shown for the same transaction, and access to each chat before and after expiry. Those three checks tell you what a fee schedule can't: whether a buyer can pay with the method you need, where the proceeds show up, and whether access ends as expected. Compare creator costs once you know which setups work for your offer.
Top comments (0)