I run Cirrela. Disclosure up front: it's our product, and this post was written with AI help, then checked by me.
Our best-selling product is weirdly specific: a 9–15 second vertical video where Santa (or an elf, Mrs Claus, the Three Kings…) says a child's first name. €6.99 / $6.99, once, no subscription. Most buyers are parents on an iPhone, mostly in the two weeks before Christmas.
The funnel most people would call stupid
We show the complete video for free — full length, full quality, our watermark on it. Only after watching it do we ask for payment, and paying removes the watermark so the parent can send it to grandma.
The "obvious" alternative — pay first, watch after — is what almost every competitor does. We chose the opposite for one reason: the product's only real risk is "will it pronounce my kid's name right?" You can't answer that with a landing page. You answer it by letting people watch the whole thing.
What the numbers say (14 days, real analytics)
- ~44 signups → 15 payments in two weeks. Almost all one-off wish videos at €5–7.
- The free preview is the conversion step, not a leak: people who watch to the end convert at a rate that would be impossible behind a paywall, because they've already emotionally bought it.
- Watermark removal is the payment trigger — not "unlock premium", just "send it without our logo". One job, one reason to pay.
Why this works for this product specifically
The preview-first model only makes sense when three things are true:
- The product is emotional, not utilitarian. Nobody "needs" a Santa video; they want to cry at it. Emotion can't be sold by a screenshot.
- Quality is the differentiator. If our video were bad, free previews would just give it away. It's good — so showing it is the marketing.
- The marginal cost of a free view is low. Each render costs real money (fal.ai), so we cap previews and refund failed renders automatically. Free, but bounded.
For a B2B tool or a utility, paywall-first is usually right. For a gift, the gift is the ad.
The trap we avoid
Every competitor in this space asks for payment before showing anything, then delivers a 240p preview that looks nothing like the ad. Parents have learned to be suspicious — Reddit threads are full of "paid $6, got garbage" complaints.
Our rule: if the free version is embarrassing, the paid version is a lie. So the free version is the real product, just watermarked. That constraint forces quality.
Takeaway
If your product's value is emotional and your quality is good, consider giving away the whole thing. The conversion math can beat a paywall — but only if "free" still costs you something bounded, and only if what they see free is exactly what they'd pay for.
— Lorenzo, founder of Cirrela
Top comments (0)