DEV Community

Donald Johnson
Donald Johnson

Posted on

Design-First vs Develop-First: Navigating the Choices in REST API Development

Building a REST API involves a crucial choice between the Design-First and Develop-First approaches. Both have unique merits and challenges, and your project's needs will dictate the best fit. This article explores these paradigms and highlights how OpenAPI/Swagger can benefit either strategy.

Design-First Approach

Characteristics

  • Design-Centric: Starts with an API contract, detailing endpoints, responses, and data types.
  • Structured Workflow: Begins with design, followed by development and testing.

Advantages and Disadvantages

  • Pros: Facilitates team collaboration, enables automated testing, produces a stable API.
  • Cons: Requires upfront time, less flexibility to change.

Develop-First Approach

Characteristics

  • Code-Centric: Development starts with code, evolving the API iteratively.
  • Flexible Workflow: Testing and documentation happen alongside development.

Advantages and Disadvantages

  • Pros: Faster initial development, flexibility for change.
  • Cons: Potential inconsistencies, risk of inadequate documentation.

Comparison Chart

Category Design-First Develop-First
Initial Focus API Contract Code
Workflow Structured Flexible
Collaboration Early, cross-team Often developer-centric
Testing Facilitated On-the-fly
Documentation Prioritized Can be secondary
Flexibility for Changes Limited High

How OpenAPI/Swagger Adds Value

For Design-First

  • Standardized Contract: Enables creation of a detailed, standard API contract.
  • Code Generation: Automates code stub and SDK creation.
  • Automated Testing: Facilitates creation of mock servers and automated tests based on the API specification.

For Develop-First

  • Documentation from Code: Generates robust API documentation directly from code annotations.
  • Built-in Validation: Compares the developed API against the OpenAPI spec for compliance.
  • Interactive Testing: Provides an interactive user interface for easy endpoint testing.

Universal Benefits

  • Better Integration: Eases compatibility issues with third-party services.
  • Rich Ecosystem: Benefits from extensive community support and tooling.

Conclusion

Whether you choose Design-First or Develop-First, incorporating OpenAPI/Swagger can provide significant advantages, making your API more robust, easier to test, and simpler to maintain. Both approaches have their pros and cons, but with OpenAPI/Swagger, you’re better equipped to develop a high-quality API.

Image of Datadog

The Future of AI, LLMs, and Observability on Google Cloud

Datadog sat down with Google’s Director of AI to discuss the current and future states of AI, ML, and LLMs on Google Cloud. Discover 7 key insights for technical leaders, covering everything from upskilling teams to observability best practices

Learn More

Top comments (0)

Speedy emails, satisfied customers

Postmark Image

Are delayed transactional emails costing you user satisfaction? Postmark delivers your emails almost instantly, keeping your customers happy and connected.

Sign up