Query: How have MPs talked about how govenments use of consultants and contractors has changed over the last few years, and the economic impact it has had on Wellington? And ironically, when the government did have to bring in outside resources, it largely went to the big four consultancies at the cost to the wider economy?
In the provided Hansard records spanning 2023 to 2025, MPs describe a sharp political and fiscal shift in government use of consultants and contractors: an initial reduction and subsequent pandemic-era rise under the Labour Government, followed by an aggressive spending cutback under the National-led Government elected in late 2023 [1] [2]. However, the provided archive excerpts contain limited evidence regarding Wellington’s broader economy—focusing on stalled infrastructure contracts rather than public-sector consultancy cuts—and do not substantiate the claim that post-cut governments ironically returned largely to the "big four" consultancies at the expense of the wider economy [3] [4].
Shifts in Government Use of Consultants and Contractors (2023–2025)
In 2023, Labour Ministers defended their record by pointing to structural changes made after taking office in 2017, while acknowledging a later pandemic-driven spike [1] [5]. Public Service Minister Andrew Little stated that removing the cap on core Government administration in 2018 and introducing quarterly reporting to the Public Service Commission reduced contractor and consultant spending from 13.4 percent of Public Service workforce spending in 2017/2018 to 10.4 percent in 2020/2021, before it rose to 14.6 percent in 2021/2022 due to COVID-19 and the Government’s reform programme [1]. Finance Minister Grant Robertson similarly noted that pre-COVID spending had been brought down to roughly 10 percent of personnel spending before creeping back up, arguing that sectors like roading planning and IT delivery are dominated by consultants and require external expertise in the absence of an entity like the former Ministry of Works [5].
National MPs contested this framing both in Opposition in 2023 and after entering Government, characterizing the Labour period as an uncontrolled blowout [6] [2]. In August 2023, Shane Reti cited Public Service Commission figures of roughly $150 million in Vote Health consultant and contractor fees over the prior year, noting that 990 consultants and contractors transitioned from the Ministry of Health into Health New Zealand alongside approximately 1,700 full-time equivalents—a 2:1 ratio of staff to external personnel [6]. Following the change of government, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon pledged to move away from infrastructure projects being "talked and talked and talked about by consultants" [7], and by October 2024, Public Service Minister Nicola Willis reported that contractor and consultant operating spending had fallen by $274 million (13 percent) year-on-year toward a $400 million reduction target [2]. In May 2025, Health Minister Simeon Brown continued to contrast National’s focus on front-line services with what he described as "hundreds of millions of dollars of wasted money [Labour] blew on consultants" [8].
Economic Impact on Wellington
The provided Hansard excerpts do not contain MPs discussing how reductions in government consultant and contractor spending affected Wellington’s local economy, retail, or hospitality sectors; that specific aspect is absent from the supplied records [2]. Instead, the only Wellington-specific economic impact raised in the provided evidence concerns the pausing, cancellation, and re-costing of construction projects under the National-led Government [3].
In February 2025, Labour MP Ginny Andersen argued that halting and re-costing infrastructure projects contributed to 13,000 construction workers leaving overseas and entrenched an economic recession [3]. Focusing on the RiverLink project as an example that "impacted significantly on the Wellington region," Andersen stated that delays caused Hutt City Council, the Wellington Regional Council, and Waka Kotahi to go their separate ways, leaving locals in the Hutt without certainty and fueling speculation that Waka Kotahi was paying daily or weekly fees—potentially "within the millions per day or week"—to signed contractors "without any shovels in the ground" [3].
Reliance on the "Big Four" Consultancies and Cost to the Wider Economy
While the question suggests a dynamic in which a government cutting internal or external resources ironically had to turn to the "big four" consultancies at a cost to the wider economy, the provided Hansard evidence only documents National Opposition MPs criticizing the Labour Government’s simultaneous expansion of the public service and reliance on large consultancies in 2023 [4] [9]. Michael Woodhouse remarked that "the industry that’s been transformed the most by this Government has been the likes of KPMG, Deloitte, and Pricewaterhouse," arguing they "must be embarrassed by the amount of work that’s coming their way from a Government that creates 14,000 more bureaucrats and still cannot get the job done without outside assistance" [4].
Similarly, Tama Potaka criticized an MBIE proposal to build its own IT platform to collate data, asking, "Was it from one of the big four, an IT consultant?" and urging the Government to let SMEs use funds directly for e-invoicing and technology solutions while reducing red tape [9]. Beyond these 2023 Opposition critiques, the provided records contain no data showing what proportion of government consultancy spending went to the "big four" firms, nor any evidence that the 2024–2025 National-led Government turned back to the "big four" after reducing overall contractor and consultant expenditure [2] [4].
Primary Sources (NZ Hansard)
- Row #596970 — Andrew Little (2023-03-08)
- Row #646870 — Nicola Willis (2024-10-17)
- Row #656704 — Ginny Andersen (2025-02-11)
- Row #597030 — Michael Woodhouse (2023-03-08)
- Row #610988 — Grant Robertson (2023-08-02)
- Row #610437 — Shane Reti (2023-08-01)
- Row #615352 — Christopher Luxon (2023-12-06)
- Row #668818 — Simeon Brown (2025-05-21)
- Row #604550 — Tama Potaka (2023-06-01)
View Agent Execution Trace (4 turns)
- [Step 1/10]
hansard_search_text({"startDate":20210101,"topK":10,"query":"consultants contractors"}) - [Step 1/10]
hansard_search_text({"startDate":20210101,"query":"consultants contractors Wellington","topK":10}) - [Step 1/10]
hansard_search_text({"startDate":20210101,"query":"\"big four\" consultants","topK":10}) - [Step 1/10]
hansard_search_text({"query":"KPMG Deloitte PwC EY","topK":10,"startDate":20210101}) - [Step 2/10]
hansard_search_text({"query":"Wellington contractors economy","topK":10,"startDate":20230101}) - [Step 2/10]
hansard_search_text({"startDate":20230101,"query":"consultants spending public service","topK":10}) - [Step 4/10]
hansard_get_speech_text({"rowIndices":[610437,604550,597030,673303,712387,727541,596970,615352,610988,668818,646870,656704,599228,609307,606544],"followContinuations":true})
Session Telemetry
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Models | Tool: gemini-4-hydrogen, Decision: gemini-decision-1, Synthesis: gemini-4-hydrogen
|
Tool (gemini-4-hydrogen) |
15,025 in / 503 out (+1,455 think) · 19.63s · $0.037223 |
Decision (gemini-decision-1) |
61,698 in / 0 out · 1.55s · $0.006170 |
Synthesis (gemini-4-hydrogen) |
4,830 in / 1,731 out (+3,601 think) · 24.76s · $0.047235 |
| Tool Turns | 4 / 10 |
| Total Latency | 46.00s |
| Total Tokens | 81,553 input / 7,290 output (88,843 total) |
| Archive Wire Read | 2102.10 KB (537 read ops) |
| Estimated Cost | $0.090821 USD (LLM: $0.090627, Storage: $0.000193) |
Top comments (0)