DEV Community

Cover image for Why Decoding Uniswap V4 is Harder Than V2 & V3
decoder man
decoder man

Posted on

Why Decoding Uniswap V4 is Harder Than V2 & V3

#ethereum #etherjs #web3 #blockchain

A transaction-level, data-engineering perspective

When people say “Uniswap V4 is just another AMM version”, that’s only true at the UX level.
From a transaction decoding and on-chain data perspective, V4 is a very different beast.

If you’ve ever built:

  • a tx decoder
  • an indexer
  • a trade analytics pipeline -or a MEV / monitoring system

you’ll immediately feel the difference.

This post explains why decoding Uniswap V4 is fundamentally harder than V2 and V3, and what changes at the data layer.

1. V2 & V3: decoding by pattern recognition

V2/V3 decoding is almost trivial:

  • One pool = one contract -> Liquidity is balance of pool contract
  • Swap logic is fixed
  • Key events:
    • Swap
    • Mint
    • Burn
  • A decoder can:
    • Identify pool address
    • Parse Swap event
    • Infer: token0 / token1 from pool contract

➡️ Event-driven, deterministic, stateless

2. Uniswap V4: everything breaks 😅

Uniswap V4 introduces a paradigm shift, not an iteration.

The biggest change

Pools are no longer contracts.

All pools live inside one singleton contract (PoolManager), and everything is keyed by a PoolId

That single design choice cascades into multiple decoding problems.

3. PoolId ≠ Pool Address

In Uniswap V4:

  • poolId is a bytes32

  • Derived from:

    • token0
    • token1
    • fee
    • tickSpacing
    • hooks

  • Problems for decoders:

    • No on-chain pool address to index
    • No ERC-20 balance per pool
    • No direct contract logs per pool

➡️ You must detect event pool initialize, save pool information to your local database before you start decoding any transactions of the pool.

4. Hooks: decoding without knowing the rules

Hooks are the real game changer.
A pool can attach arbitrary logic at:

  • beforeSwap
  • afterSwap
  • beforeModifyPosition
  • afterModifyPosition ...

From a decoder’s point of view:

  • Swap behavior is no longer deterministic

  • Token flows may:

    • be modified
    • be redirected
    • be conditionally executed

  • Even worse:

    • Hooks are external contracts
    • They may emit their own events
    • Or emit nothing at all

➡️ You cannot decode V4 swaps correctly by reading PoolManager logs alone.

5. One tx ≠ one action

- In V2/V3:

   - One swap tx ≈ one swap action
   - transparently token transfers
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

- In V4:

   - A single tx can include:
   - multiple pool interactions
   - nested swaps
   - hook-triggered internal swaps
   - non-swap token movements
   - aggregated token movements
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

➡️ Decoding becomes stateful, not event-local.

6. Event semantics are weaker

Another subtle but painful difference:

V2/V3 events are semantic
→ “this is a swap, this is mint, this is burn”

V4 logs are often mechanical
→ balance deltas, internal calls, state updates

To reconstruct a “swap”, you may need:

  • call trace
  • storage reads
  • hook-specific logic
  • token balance diffs

➡️ You’re rebuilding meaning, not parsing events.

7. Why generic decoders fail on V4

Most existing decoders assume:

  • pool = contract
  • swap = event
  • tokens = known upfront

These assumptions fail in V4.

A V4-capable decoder must:

  • Resolve PoolId → PoolKey
  • Track pool state off-chain
  • Understand hook execution paths
  • Aggregate multi-step flows into one semantic action

➡️ This is closer to program analysis than log parsing.

8. Practical implications for infra teams

If you’re building:

  • analytics dashboards
  • tax tools
  • MEV monitors
  • compliance / forensics
  • copy-trading systems

Then V4 forces you to rethink:

  • indexing strategy
  • storage model
  • decoding abstractions

“Just listen to events” is no longer enough.

Closing thoughts

Uniswap V4 isn’t harder because it’s poorly designed.
It’s harder because it’s more expressive.
That expressiveness moves complexity:

from smart contracts

to off-chain decoding and interpretation

For data engineers and infra builders, V4 is not an upgrade — it’s a new problem class.

About txdecoder.xyz

Transaction decoding API — standardizing blockchain data into one unified, readable schema on Ethereum, Base, BSC, Solana

Website: https://txdecoder.xyz/
X: https://x.com/txdecoder_xyz
Telegram: https://t.me/txdecoder
Telegram channel: https://t.me/txdecoder_announcements
Blog: https://medium.com/@txdecoder

Top comments (0)