Jon, thanks for mirroring my exact thoughts. It matches all my knowledge which i consider rather solid. Still i got in doubt and was rather hesitant to oppose the claims in this post when i first read it, but it shook the foundations of my understanding how the web works.
I know the feeling. I am always hesitant to ask in case I am wrong, but I figured what the hell.
If I am wrong & the author has references to back up his claims I look silly for a bit and it adds more context for future readers like you and me. I also learn about a new attack vector as an added bonus.
If I am right, hopefully it leads to the author updating the post a bit to fix the mistake and we all live happily ever after (or until the next Heartbleed).
What you say is true, the attacker will not have access to the cookies themselves. However there are trickier vector attacks he can perform, see for example
We’re a place where coders share, stay up-to-date and grow their careers.
We strive for transparency and don't collect excess data.