Quarantine asks inboxes to put failing email in spam; reject asks them to refuse it. Use quarantine as a step, then reject once every service that sends as you passes.
The difference
DMARC has three policies. Each one only applies to email that fails both SPF and DKIM for your domain:
-
p=none: do nothing, just send me reports. -
p=quarantine: put it in the spam folder. -
p=reject: refuse it, so it never arrives.
Reject is the setting that actually stops other people sending email as your domain. Quarantine still lets a fake land in someone's spam folder, where it can be found and opened.
Which one to use
- Start at
p=nonewith a report address, and read the reports for two to four weeks. - Fix every real service that fails: your mailbox, newsletter tool, CRM, billing and support tools.
- Move to
p=quarantine. The oldpct=25halfway step is retired in the current standard (RFC 9989). - When the reports show only fakes failing, move to
p=reject. For a trial week, publishp=reject; t=yfirst: inboxes handle it as quarantine.
When to stay at quarantine
Stay there while a service you can't control still fails, for example an old tool that can't sign with your domain. Moving to reject would send its email nowhere.
Common questions
Is p=reject safe for a business?
Yes, once your reports show every service you use passes. It only blocks email that fails both SPF and DKIM for your domain.
How long should I stay at quarantine?
Until your DMARC reports show no real email failing, often a few weeks. There's no fixed rule.
Do the big inboxes require reject?
No. Bulk senders must have a DMARC record, and p=none meets that rule. Reject is what protects your name.
First published on DNSFix. Check your own domain free at dnsfix.com.
Top comments (0)