Flattening swaps include: entries for the IP addresses behind them, to get under SPF's 10-lookup limit. It works, but breaks silently when a service changes its addresses.
What flattening is
An SPF record may use at most 10 DNS lookups. Each include: costs at least one, and the services you include often add more. Flattening replaces each include with the IP addresses it points to (ip4: and ip6: entries), which cost no lookups.
Pros
- Gets you under the 10-lookup limit at once.
- No change at your email services.
Cons
- It goes stale. When a service adds or changes a sending address, your copied list is wrong and its email fails SPF, with no warning.
- Long records may need splitting, and big lists are hard to read and check.
Safer options, in order
- Remove services you no longer use. This fixes most records.
- Move a bulk sender to its own subdomain (for example news.yourbusiness.com) with its own SPF record.
- Rely on DKIM for tools that support it, so they don't need to be in SPF for DMARC to pass.
- If you still need flattening, use a service that re-checks the addresses automatically, and watch your DMARC reports.
Common questions
Is SPF flattening bad?
Not by itself, but a hand-flattened record breaks when a service changes its addresses. Only flatten with automatic updates.
How do I count my SPF lookups?
Run the SPF checker: it counts every lookup, including the ones inside each include.
First published on DNSFix. Check your own domain free at dnsfix.com.
Top comments (0)