In the fast-paced world of ecommerce, especially for agencies managing multiple client accounts, staying current with platform updates and best practices is essential. A recurring and vital discussion centers on Meta ad campaign structure. Recently, a highly informative conversation within an ecommerce community highlighted a key question many of us face: is it more effective to use one ad per adset or multiple ads per adset within a CBO (Campaign Budget Optimization) campaign?
The original participant in the discussion shared their current setup: a CBO testing campaign and a CBO winning ads campaign, both configured with one ad per adset. While acknowledging the profitability of this method, they sought clarification on whether a more structured approach—grouping several similar ads under a single adset—could offer greater advantages. This common dilemma provides an excellent opportunity to examine modern Meta ad strategy, particularly for agencies aiming to refine their workflow automation for agencies and improve client results.
A crucial insight from the community thread emphasized a significant shift in Meta's advertising philosophy, especially after the Andromeda update. The traditional approach often involved carefully segmenting adsets to target specific customer personas. However, the modern Meta algorithm operates differently now: “Your ads are now your targeting.”
For agency teams, this fundamental change means that Meta’s advanced AI, when provided with broad targeting and a variety of creatives within an adset, can independently determine which audience segments respond best to particular ads. It then dynamically prioritizes and delivers those ads to the most receptive users. As one community member accurately observed, this method often “works significantly better than the ‘old’ way of trying to scale a single ad in an ABO campaign.” This development allows agencies to concentrate more on creative development and less on extremely granular audience segmentation, trusting Meta's machine learning to find the optimal match.
The Rationale for Multiple Ads Per Adset: Leveraging Meta's Algorithm
The primary reason for deploying multiple ads within a single adset lies in Meta's learning phase and budget allocation mechanisms. A key contributor in the discussion explained this concept effectively:
Enhanced Learning Phase Efficiency: Each adset initiates its own distinct learning phase and manages a separate budget pool. When an agency operates with one ad per adset across, for instance, five adsets, it generates five individual learning phases. Each of these phases then competes for a portion of the daily budget. If the daily budget is modest (e.g., $100 spread across five adsets), each learning phase receives only $20 per day. This amount often falls below the necessary threshold for achieving stable signal and efficient optimization in most ecommerce accounts, potentially leading to inconsistent delivery and fragmented data.
Consolidated Budget and Real-time Optimization: Conversely, when multiple ads are placed within a single adset, Meta views them as competing creatives within a unified auction environment. This setup enables the algorithm to dynamically reallocate budget towards the top-performing ads in real-time. The learning phase completes much faster, yielding cleaner, more dependable data on which creative genuinely resonates with the target audience.
Outdated Recommendations: The advice to use “1 ad per adset” is largely a remnant from a previous era where interest stacking and audience splitting were the main optimization strategies. This conceptual model became less effective following iOS 14.5 and is definitively not the optimal approach in the current post-Andromeda landscape.
By adopting a strategy that includes multiple ads per adset, agencies can furnish Meta's algorithm with more data points and increased flexibility, ultimately leading to more efficient spending and improved overall performance.
Practical Structure Recommendations for Agencies
For ecommerce agencies overseeing diverse client portfolios, a streamlined and efficient Meta ad structure is paramount. Based on expert consensus, a robust structure for many ecommerce clients within the current Meta ecosystem typically includes the following:
Campaign Level: Utilize a single Advantage+ Shopping Campaign. This approach harnesses Meta's most advanced automation capabilities for broad targeting and optimal budget distribution.
Adset Level: Limit the number of adsets to a maximum of 2-3. These can be intelligently segmented based on meaningful criteria, such as prospecting audiences versus site visitors (retargeting), or specific geographical regions if the client sells into multiple countries. It is crucial to avoid overly granular segmentation that could spread the budget too thinly.
Ad Level: Within each adset, incorporate 4-6 distinct ads. These ads should showcase various angles, hooks, and formats (e.g., video, static image, carousel) to provide Meta with a broad range of creative options for testing and optimization.
Budget Considerations: Exercise caution to prevent spreading your budget too thinly. If a client's daily ad budget is below $1,000, simplifying the account structure and consolidating creatives within fewer adsets is often considerably more effective than complex, multi-adset approaches typically employed by brands spending millions.
Beyond Ad Structure: Ensuring Genuine Agency Profitability and Growth
While optimizing Meta ad structure is crucial for client success, a community member wisely encouraged a deeper examination of the definition of “profitability.” They pointed out that agencies and brands frequently miscalculate profitability or become overly focused on it too soon, which can impede growth. For ecommerce agencies, true profitability and sustained growth depend on more than just ad performance; they necessitate a holistic approach to operations and client management.
This is precisely where an integrated agency delivery management platform like EShopSet becomes indispensable. EShopSet functions as a central client project hub for agencies, enabling teams not only to manage ad campaigns efficiently but also to track broader client financials, project timelines, and overall delivery. By connecting ad performance data with operational metrics, agencies can achieve a clearer understanding of their genuine margins and client ROI.
Furthermore, EShopSet integrates seamlessly with powerful tools such as HubSpot, significantly enhancing an agency's capabilities:
HubSpot CRM: Centralize all client communication, manage relationships effectively, and track every interaction, thereby ensuring a consistent and high-quality client experience.
HubSpot Sales Hub: Streamline your agency's sales process, from initial lead generation to successful deal closing, ensuring a robust pipeline for sustained growth.
HubSpot Commerce & Storefront Insights: Gain deeper insights into your clients' actual sales performance directly from their storefronts. This enables more informed ad strategy adjustments and provides a clearer picture of their Revenue Operations (RevOps).
Holistic RevOps: By integrating ad campaign data, client project management, and financial tracking, EShopSet assists agencies in achieving robust RevOps. This ensures that all revenue-generating activities are precisely aligned with operational efficiency and overall profitability.
By effectively leveraging such integrations, agencies can move beyond merely optimizing ad structure to optimizing their entire delivery operation. This ensures that profitability is accurately calculated and that growth remains sustainable. This comprehensive approach empowers agencies to not only deliver exceptional results for clients but also to thrive financially themselves.
In conclusion, the discussion regarding one ad per adset versus multiple ads per adset in Meta campaigns has largely been resolved in favor of the latter, particularly in the post-Andromeda era. This modern methodology, which emphasizes creative-driven optimization within consolidated adsets, yields greater efficiency and superior performance. For ecommerce agencies, adopting this strategy is a critical step toward maximizing client ad spend. However, true agency success extends beyond mere ad structure to encompass robust operational management. Platforms like EShopSet, serving as your central operations workspace and integrating with powerful tools such as HubSpot, offer the comprehensive solution needed to streamline workflows, ensure accurate profitability, and drive sustainable growth for both your agency and your clients.
Top comments (0)