Your merchant of record can close your store overnight — a download seller's Plan B checklist

Posted by the FileFreight team. We build a flat-rate delivery tool for digital sellers: secure download links, per-buyer PDF stamping, and license keys. In October 2026 we read through the newest 1-star Trustpilot reviews for four merchant-of-record (MoR) platforms — Lemon Squeezy, Creem, Polar, and Paddle. What follows is the pattern we kept seeing, and the checklist it points to.

Spend an hour reading those reviews and one story repeats, almost word for word, across all four platforms:

1. The seller sells normally — sometimes for months, sometimes for over a year.
2. A "risk review" or identity/KYB check flags the account, often right after sales grow.
3. The store is closed or payouts are frozen. Reviewers report balances held for 90–180 days, and in a few cases five figures held with no release date.
4. Support replies with templates. There is no real appeal path.

Specific reviewers described: an established account killed after a KYB rejection (Creem, October 2026); roughly $8,000 blocked (Creem, July 2026); an AI product banned with a 180-day payout hold (Polar); a store identity verification rejected twice with no way to appeal (Lemon Squeezy, October 2026); a SaaS account suspended as soon as its MRR grew (Paddle, October 2026).

These are one-sided reviews, and platforms rarely get to tell their side — treat any single story with skepticism. But the pattern is consistent enough, across enough independent sellers, that it deserves a plan.

Why this is structural, not a scandal

A merchant of record carries your tax and fraud risk. It is the legal seller of your product in your buyers' countries, it remits VAT and sales tax, and it eats the regulatory consequences when something looks wrong. When its risk model twitches, de-risking your account is — from its side — the rational move.

That's the trade you make for MoR convenience: one counterparty can end your checkout, your delivery, and your access to your own revenue in a single decision. The fee (typically around 5% per sale) is the visible cost. The single point of failure is the hidden one.

You may still decide the trade is worth it. But you should make it with a Plan B already in place, not improvised during a payout freeze.

The Plan B checklist

None of this requires leaving your MoR today. It just makes sure you could keep selling if you had to.

1. Export your customer list weekly. Names, emails, what they bought, when. If your only copy lives inside the platform that just closed you, you cannot even tell your buyers what happened.
2. Keep your master files outside the platform. Source files, final deliverables, and license-key records in storage you control. Rebuilding a catalog from a closed dashboard is the slowest part of any recovery.
3. Own your front door. Sell from a domain and page you control, even if checkout happens elsewhere. An audience that only knows your platform storefront URL is an audience you can lose overnight.
4. Keep a direct path warm. An account with a payment processor in your own name (e.g., your own Stripe) plus a delivery method that doesn't depend on the MoR — secure expiring download links, per-buyer PDF stamping, license keys with revocation. A dormant backup you have tested once beats a signup form filled out in a panic.
5. Withdraw on a short cadence. Money sitting in a platform balance is money exposed to a hold. Shorter payout cycles shrink the blast radius.
6. Pre-write the buyer email. One short message — what happened, where existing buyers can re-download their purchases, where to buy now. Draft it while you're calm.

Where a tool like ours fits — and the honest caveats

FileFreight is that delivery layer: you sell through your own Stripe account, we handle secure download delivery, PDF stamping, and license keys for a flat $19/month with 0% per-sale fees. If your MoR closed tomorrow, your delivery and your payment account would still be yours.

The caveats are real, and we'll state them plainly:

1. We are not a merchant of record. We do not handle VAT or sales tax for you. Payments go to your own Stripe, so tax responsibility stays with you. For many sellers — especially selling heavily into the EU — MoR tax handling is genuinely valuable, and giving it up is a real cost, not a footnote.
2. No automatic importer. We can't one-click migrate your catalog (yet). We do offer free manual migration help — we rebuild your products, files, and license keys by hand.
3. We're delivery-only, not a storefront builder or a course platform, and we're not a Shopify app. You still need your own page to sell from.
4. Card processing fees still apply — the 0% is our cut, not the card network's.

Who should stay exactly where they are

• You sell mostly to the EU/UK and VAT compliance is the thing you most want to never think about? An MoR is earning its fee. Keep it — just run the checklist above as insurance.
• Your volume is small and a closure would be annoying rather than existential? The checklist is an afternoon of work; do items 1–3 and move on.
• Your store is your income, and one frozen payout would hurt? Then the single-point-of-failure question deserves an hour this week, not after it happens.

The platforms aren't villains and this isn't a call to abandon them. It's a call to notice what you actually rented: checkout, delivery, tax handling — and your customers' only path to you — from a single counterparty that can revoke all of it at once.

Keep the convenience. Just own a copy of everything you'd need to survive losing it.

---

Complaint patterns: 1-star Trustpilot reviews for Lemon Squeezy, Creem, Polar, and Paddle read October 2026 (reviewer-reported; platforms' perspectives are not represented on review pages). Our pricing: getfilefreight.com/#pricing.