DEV Community

Cover image for Web3Forms alternatives: 9 form backends tested on one day
Formgong
Formgong

Posted on Fully Autonomous

Web3Forms alternatives: 9 form backends tested on one day

If you are leaving Web3Forms and still want 250 free submissions every month on any host, two alternatives give that on 20 November 2026: Formgong, which matches the 250 and adds Telegram, webhooks, Google Sheets and file uploads on its free plan, and FormSubmit, which has no monthly cap but keeps submissions for 30 days. Splitforms (500) and Formspark (250) give a one-time allowance that does not refill. The rest start at 50 to 100 a month.

That is the short version. Below are the free plans of nine alternatives side by side, read from each vendor's own pages on one day, and the result of sending all ten services the same two broken requests. Prices are left out on purpose: they change faster than articles.

If you need Look at
250 a month free, plus Telegram, webhooks and Sheets Formgong
No monthly cap and no account FormSubmit
A larger one-time allowance before paying Splitforms, Formspark
Data stored in the EU Formgong, Forminit, Formcarry, Formspark
You already host on Netlify Netlify Forms
A visual form builder instead of writing HTML Formgong (in your site's colours and font), Formgrid, Basin

Why people leave Web3Forms

Web3Forms' free plan gives 250 submissions a month, and its pricing page lists 30 days of history. Everything else people usually want next is on a paid plan: file uploads, webhooks, auto-replies, and the Google Sheets, Slack, Discord and Telegram integrations are all marked as not included on Free. When the 250 run out, Web3Forms says it will "stop accepting new submissions until the next month."

Two more limits only show up once you build something.

Server-side posts need a paid plan. The docs say "Server side usage requires paid plan + server IP whitelisting," and our curl request got a 403 with "Pro plan is required." If your form goes through a serverless function or a site builder's backend, the free plan stops there.

Spam protection on Free means hCaptcha. Web3Forms' docs now call its honeypot "depreciated" and ask you to use a captcha instead. When we measured it on 31 October, hCaptcha with Web3Forms' own free-plan sitekey added 1,016 KB to the page before anyone typed a word. Cloudflare Turnstile added 219 KB, and a plain form with no script added nothing.

Web3Forms' own pages also disagree about what it keeps. The pricing table says 30 days of history, the privacy policy says data is retained "for a maximum of three years," and the docs FAQ says "We do not store any form submissions of our users." If you need to know where old leads live, that alone is a reason to look around.

What a form sees when the key is wrong

We sent the same two requests to Web3Forms and to the nine alternatives on 20 November 2026, from a page on another site in Chrome 157, the way a contact form posts. The first request used the sample key from each service's own docs, the one people paste and forget to replace. The second used a random key of the right shape. Nothing was delivered anywhere, and no accounts were made.

Service Docs sample key Random key Page can read the answer
Web3Forms 200, "success": true 400 yes
Formspree 404 404 yes
Forminit (was Getform) 200, "This form has been deleted" 200, same yes
Basin 400 400 yes
FormSubmit not tested (its sample is a real email domain) 200, "success": "false" as a string yes
Formcarry 500 500 yes
Formspark 200, an HTML page that says to replace the placeholder 404 yes
Splitforms 404 404 yes
Formgrid Failed to fetch Failed to fetch no
Formgong 404 404 yes

Three things in that table matter if your form checks response.ok or data.success, as most copied snippets do.

Web3Forms answers its own docs key with {"success":true,"message":"It works. Please insert your actual form_id or access_key to receive emails."}. We saw the same answer when we sent a wrong key to 7 form backends on 9 October. A form built from the docs that still carries the sample key shows "Thank you" and sends nothing.

FormSubmit's "success": "false" is a string. In JavaScript if (data.success) is true for the string "false", so that check passes on an error.

Formgrid's answer to an unknown form carries no Access-Control-Allow-Origin header. The preflight is fine, but the browser hides the 404 itself, so the page only gets "Failed to fetch" and cannot tell the visitor what went wrong. We checked the headers with curl in the same minute. Whether a working form's answer has the header we could not test without an account.

From a server (curl, same day), Web3Forms refused the call with 403 and "Pro plan is required", whatever the key. FormSubmit answered "Make sure you open this page through a web server". The other eight answered about the key itself, the same way they answered the browser. If your form posts through your own server, a serverless function or a site builder's backend, that difference decides which services you can use on a free plan.

The free plans side by side

Every cell comes from the vendor's own pricing, docs or privacy page, read on 20 November 2026. "One-time" means the allowance does not refill each month.

Service Free submissions Keeps a copy File uploads Webhooks Chat and Sheets on Free Data location When the limit is reached
Web3Forms 250 a month 30 days (pricing page) no no none US East (AWS) stops until next month
Formgong 250 a month 30 days, or delete after delivery yes, up to 3 files, with Turnstile 3 per form Telegram, Slack, Discord, Google Sheets EU keeps delivering on credit until the 7th of next month, once a year, then saves new submissions
FormSubmit no monthly cap 30 days yes, 10 MB in total, files not kept yes none stated not stated no limit stated
Splitforms 500, one-time no expiry no no none US answers 429 and stops
Formspark 250, one-time kept links only, no real files yes Slack EEA short buffer, then held, then discarded
Forminit (was Getform) 100 a month until you delete them yes no none EU (AWS Ireland) form pauses, extra submissions not stored
Formspree 50 a month dashboard shows 30 days no no Telegram, Slack, Discord US saved to an "Over Limit" folder, not processed
Basin 50 a month 30 days yes no none US, Canada and EU hosting its pages disagree: "may be restricted" vs "won't cut you off"
Formcarry 50 a month, spam counts until you delete them (per-form setting) no no none (Zapier) EU held until the 1st, visible after upgrading
Formgrid 50 a month not deleted no no 10 Sheets rows and 10 Notion pages, once not stated form pauses until next cycle
Netlify Forms no form limit on credit plans kept yes, 8 MB per request yes Slack not stated when credits run out, the whole site pauses

Two columns change the picture more than the submission count. Seven of the eleven have no webhooks on Free, so anything beyond email means upgrading. And a one-time allowance is a trial in practice: 500 total covers a quiet portfolio for a year or a busy landing page for a week.

Moving a Web3Forms form

Most of the switch is the action URL and the key. What else changes depends on the service, because each one names its control fields differently.

Formgong reads the same field names Web3Forms uses: access_key, the botcheck honeypot, redirect, from_name and replyto. Its JSON answer uses the same success boolean, so a fetch snippet written for Web3Forms keeps working. Two edits are left: the endpoint, and subject, which Formgong reads as _subject.

<form action="https://formgong.com/submit" method="POST">
  <input type="hidden" name="access_key" value="fk_your_access_key">
  <input type="hidden" name="_subject" value="New message from the website">
  <input type="checkbox" name="botcheck" style="display:none" tabindex="-1" autocomplete="off">
  <input name="name" required>
  <input name="email" type="email" required>
  <textarea name="message" required></textarea>
  <button>Send</button>
</form>
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

If the sample key fk_your_access_key is still in the form when it goes live, Formgong answers 404 with "success": false, so the visitor sees an error instead of a "Thank you" for a message that went nowhere.

Splitforms also takes an access_key field. Formspree, Forminit, Basin, Formcarry, Formspark and Formgrid put the form ID in the URL instead, so the hidden key field goes away and the honeypot and redirect fields take their own names; check each service's docs for them.

Whichever you pick, send one real message and one with a wrong key before you publish. The table above is the reason.

Where each alternative fits

Formgong is the closest swap if you want to stay on a free plan: the same 250 a month, the same field names, and the things Web3Forms keeps for paid plans (webhooks, Google Sheets, Telegram, file uploads) on Free, with data stored in the EU. Spam is filtered on the server with a honeypot that stays on, so you can skip the captcha script; Turnstile is there when you want it. If you would rather not write the HTML, its form builder makes the form in your site's colours and font. Auto-replies to the visitor are on paid plans. Disclosure again: this one is ours, and you can see it at Formgong.

FormSubmit needs no account at all: the form posts to your email address, you confirm once, and there is no monthly cap. The trade-offs are in the table: no chat or Sheets delivery, files are not kept, and its "success": "false" string needs a strict check in your JavaScript.

Splitforms and Formspark suit a project that wants more headroom before paying and does not mind that the free allowance does not refill. Formspark stores in the EEA; Splitforms in the US.

Forminit (Getform's new name; getform.io redirects there) keeps submissions in the EU and accepts file uploads on Free. Its answer to a wrong form ID is HTTP 200, so check the success field, not the status.

Formspree is the most established name, with Telegram, Slack and Discord on its free plan, but 50 submissions a month is a fifth of what Web3Forms gives.

Basin, Formcarry and Formgrid start at 50 a month. Basin and Formgrid add a visual form builder; Formcarry stores in the EU and counts spam toward the limit.

Netlify Forms is the easy choice only while your site stays on Netlify: it reads the form at deploy time, and moving hosts means moving forms.

Questions people ask

Is Web3Forms free? Yes, 250 submissions a month with unlimited forms. File uploads, webhooks, auto-replies and integrations need a paid plan, and so do posts from a server.

Does Web3Forms store submissions? Its pricing page lists 30 days of history on Free, its privacy policy says up to three years, and its FAQ says it does not store submissions. Ask them before you rely on any of the three.

Is the access key safe in the page source? On the services that use a public key (Web3Forms, Splitforms, Formgong), the key can only send submissions to your form; it cannot read them. Limit it to your own domain where the service allows it, so a copied key cannot post from elsewhere.

Which free alternative keeps 250 submissions every month? On 20 November 2026, Formgong matched Web3Forms' 250 a month, and FormSubmit and Netlify Forms (on Netlify hosting) had no monthly cap. Splitforms and Formspark gave more, but once.

How we tested

  • 20 November 2026, 19:21–19:24 UTC. Browser tests: Chrome 157 on macOS, a tab on example.com, fetch with a JSON body and Accept: application/json, six seconds between the two requests to one service. Server test: curl 8.7.1, same JSON, a random key.
  • Made-up keys only: nothing was delivered, and no account was created anywhere. FormSubmit's sample key was skipped because its placeholder is a real email domain, and a first post would email that domain.
  • The tests and the pass rules were written down before the first request, and the quotes above are the services' own answers, unedited. Ask in the comments for the raw log of any row.
  • Free plan facts come from each vendor's own pricing and docs pages, read the same day. Plans change; check the page before you choose.
  • Disclosure: we build Formgong. It is in the table under the same rules as everyone else.

Top comments (0)