DEV Community

Gijela
Gijela

Posted on

The Reddit archive that returns nothing: what 120 deleted posts actually recovered

Last week I published a test of 120 deleted Reddit posts against public archives. The short version: 51 of 120 came back with usable text, and every single one came from two subreddits.

This post is about the part nobody writes up — why recovery splits that way, and what it means if you're building anything on top of these archives.

The data

Subreddit 2021 2024
r/buildapc 14/15 (93%) 15/15 (100%)
r/homelab 10/15 (67%) 12/15 (80%)
r/AskReddit 0/15 0/15
r/pics 0/15 0/15
Total 24/60 (40%) 27/60 (45%)

Method: 15 posts per subreddit per year, taken from two single days (2021-06-01 and 2024-06-01), no hand-picking. A record counted as recovered only if the archive returned real text longer than a [deleted] / [removed] placeholder.

The counterintuitive part: age doesn't matter

2021 scored 40%. 2024 scored 45%. Two years apart, same result.

That kills the intuition that older posts are harder to recover. They aren't — the community is the variable, not the year.

Why: the archive reads the post the day it's created

The median gap between a post's creation and the archive's capture of it was 0 days.

So the question isn't "how old is this post" — it's "was it still up when the crawler looked?"

  • r/buildapc / r/homelab: posts survive long enough to be captured. Body stored.
  • r/AskReddit: automod removes posts within minutes. By the time the crawler arrives, the body is already [removed].
  • r/pics: image-first. Archives index text, not media. Nothing to store.

This is the whole story in three bullets. Everything else follows.

The two sources that didn't help

PullPush returned HTTP 429 on every single request during the test window:

{"error":"Rate limit exceeded. This website does not provide free scraping
resources for agents. Please contact the administrator on Discord if you're
interested in a paid scraping service."}
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

A browser User-Agent gets the same response. Other people reported it independently. Whatever PullPush's actual coverage is, this test says nothing about it — only that it was unreachable.

The Wayback Machine had a snapshot URL for 15 of 20 posts sampled (75%). I opened one. 550 KB of HTML, the page rendered, the comment tree was there — and where the post body should have been, there was [deleted].

A snapshot URL is not a recovered thread. Wayback tells you a thread existed and roughly when. It rarely gives you back what was written.

What this means if you're building on these archives

1. "Use an archive" is not advice.
Which archive matters enormously, and the one most guides name first returned nothing at all.

2. Coverage is a property of the community, not the date.
A 2021 r/buildapc post is far more recoverable than a 2024 r/AskReddit post. Any tool quoting a flat "we recover N% of deleted posts" is averaging two populations that behave nothing alike.

3. Snapshots ≠ content.
If your code counts "found a Wayback snapshot" as a recovery, you're wrong 100% of the time in this sample.

4. Say "not found" when it's not found.
Filling the page with placeholders to look successful is worse than admitting the archive never had it. I had to fix exactly this in my own implementation — a 10-second timeout was being swallowed and rendered as "No Results Found", indistinguishable from a genuinely empty result.

The method, so you can check me

PLACEHOLDERS = {"[deleted]", "[removed]", ""}
MIN_REAL_BODY = max(len(p) for p in PLACEHOLDERS)  # 9

def classify(body):
    body = (body or "").strip()
    if len(body) > MIN_REAL_BODY:
        return "S"      # recovered
    return "F"          # placeholder or empty
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Anything not longer than the longest placeholder is a miss. Harsh, but it's the only rule that survives contact with real archive data.

Two caveats worth stating: 120 posts is a small sample chosen to compare community types, not to estimate a sitewide rate. And every number is stamped 2026-11-15 — archives change, so re-run before quoting later.


The full breakdown with per-record data is at Reddit Archive Availability Test. I maintain ViewDeletedReddit, which queries these archives together and labels which one supplied each result.

Top comments (0)