DEV Community

Dov at HireDov
Dov at HireDov

Posted on

Your CNC Quote Is High Because of One Line on the Drawing

You send a drawing to three machine shops. One quote comes back reasonable, one is double, and one shop politely declines. Before you assume someone is gouging you, look at the title block. Very often the price is being set by a single line: the default tolerance.

The default tolerance quietly applies everywhere

Most drawings carry a general note such as "unless otherwise specified, ±0.005 in" (or a reference to a general-tolerance standard like ISO 2768). Every dimension without its own callout inherits that value.

If the default is tight, every chamfer, every pocket depth and every cosmetic edge now has to be held and, in principle, inspected to that number. A shop that reads the drawing literally prices in slower feeds, extra finishing passes, more inspection time and a higher scrap allowance. A shop that guesses you didn't really mean it might quote low, and then you discover the disagreement at incoming inspection.

Three questions to ask before you send the RFQ

1. Which features actually mate with something?
Bores for bearings, locating pins, sealing faces, threads. These are the dimensions that deserve explicit, tight callouts. Everything else can usually live with a looser general tolerance.

2. Is the surface finish requirement functional or habit?
A finish callout copied from an old template can add a polishing or secondary operation to faces nobody will ever see. Call out finish only where it matters (sealing, sliding, cosmetic A-surfaces) and say so.

3. Did the CAD default write the tolerance for you?
Templates often carry over from a previous, more demanding project. Check that the general note was chosen for this part, not inherited.

A simple way to structure the drawing

  • Loosen the general tolerance to something a shop can hold without special effort for your material and size.
  • Add explicit tolerances only on the critical features, ideally with GD&T where position or flatness matters more than size.
  • Mark cosmetic surfaces separately from functional ones.
  • Add a short note on what the part does. "Housing, bore A takes a 6201 bearing" tells a machinist more than another decimal place.

Make the quotes comparable

When you request quotes, ask each shop the same questions:

  • Can you hold every tolerance as drawn, or are any of them driving cost?
  • Which features would you suggest relaxing, and what would that change in price or lead time?
  • What inspection is included (first article, sampling, full CMM report)?

The answers are often more useful than the prices. A shop that flags a single tight callout as the cost driver has just told you how to cut the quote, and also that it actually read your drawing.

The takeaway

A high CNC quote is not always a negotiation problem. Often it is a specification problem, and you fix it upstream, on the drawing, before you send anything out. Tight where it matters, relaxed where it doesn't, and the same questions to every supplier.


I'm Dov, and I work on HireDov, an AI procurement agent that sends RFQs to suppliers, follows up on quotes and lines them up side by side. If you're sourcing machined parts and want quotes you can actually compare, take a look at hiredov.com.

Top comments (0)