DEV Community

Jim.btc
Jim.btc

Posted on

Building a Music Player Where Each Play Is a Payment

On 19 November I opened a wall of 1,000 free music players. Every play pays the artist the moment it starts, the platform takes nothing, and every play is on a public record. Here's how it works, why I built it, and what I want to find out.

1000 Free Players

When you stream a song, the artist gets paid. Eventually. The money goes into a pool, the pool is split by share of total streams, the share passes through a distributor, a label or a collecting society, and a statement turns up months later. By then nobody can trace a payment back to the play that earned it.

I wanted to see what the opposite looks like in practice. So I built a music player where each play is paid to the artist at the moment the song starts, the platform's cut is 0%, and the play itself is written to a public record that anyone can check.

Then, to find out whether normal listeners would actually use it, I gave 1,000 of them away.

For builders, the short version: the player is claimed with a WebAuthn passkey, so there's no wallet or seed phrase on the listener's side, and each player is funded up front so a play never needs the listener to approve a payment. Everything else in this post is about why those two choices matter.

A wall of 1,000 discs

The players live on one page, xtrata.xyz/players, laid out as a wall of 1,000 discs. Getting one takes three steps:

  1. Pick a disc.
  2. Claim it with your face or fingerprint. It's a passkey, so there's no password, no email form and nothing to download.
  3. Your first song starts playing.

Each player comes with plays already paid for, anywhere from 50 to 1,000. You don't know which you've got until you claim it. The wall hides five tiers:

Tier Players on the wall
Diamond (1,000 plays) 5
Gold (500 plays) 10
Silver (250 plays) 20
Bronze (100 plays) 100
Classic (50 plays) 865

Once a disc is claimed it shows its colour, so the wall slowly reveals where the Diamonds were. Nobody, including us, knows in advance which disc hides one.

A player plays any song in the catalogue. Liking a song adds it to your own playlist, so over time the player becomes a record of what you love.

Where the money from one play goes

When you press play, the payment for that play is made there and then. It goes to two places:

  • The artist. This is the point of the whole thing.
  • The network that records the play. A small fee to the network that writes the play into the public record.

The platform takes 0%. Not a percentage, not a processing fee, not a minimum payout threshold. There's no pool to divide up at the end of the month, because there's nothing to pool. Each play pays for itself.

0% PLatform Fees

That sounds simple, and it is. The interesting part is what it removes. There's no statement to decode, no reconciliation between a distributor's numbers and a platform's numbers, and no wait. A musician can watch a play happen and see the payment attached to it in the same moment.

The free players work because the plays on them are prepaid. Xtrata donated the funds that cover them, so a listener who claims a player never pays anything, and the artist still gets paid in full for every play.

Listening data that nobody owns

Every play and every like is recorded on-chain. In practice that means the record of who listened to what, and what was paid for it, sits in public, where anyone can read it and nobody can edit it or switch it off.

On the big streaming services, listening data is one of the most valuable things they hold, and artists see a filtered slice of it through a dashboard. Here the data isn't held by anyone in particular. We can't gatekeep it, change it after the fact, or charge an artist to see their own numbers. Neither can anyone else.

For an artist, that turns a few questions that are normally hard into easy ones. How many times was this song played today? Who has liked it? Was every play paid? The answers are on the record, and they don't depend on trusting us.

Hiding the plumbing

Yes, this runs on a blockchain. The players and payments live on Stacks, which settles to Bitcoin. I'm not going to pretend otherwise. But a listener should never need to know that, any more than they need to know how a card payment clears.

Most on-chain music projects ask a newcomer to install a wallet, write down a seed phrase, buy a token and approve a transaction before they hear a note. Almost everyone leaves at the first of those steps. So the design goal was to remove all of them:

  • No wallet. The player is claimed with a passkey, the same face or fingerprint you use to unlock your phone.
  • No buying. The plays are prepaid, so there's nothing to fund.
  • No jargon. The page talks about discs, plays and artists. The on-chain parts are there for anyone who wants to check them, and invisible to anyone who doesn't.

That's also why the main thing I've asked people to do is give a player away rather than keep it. The real test isn't whether people who already understand this stuff can use it. It's whether someone's mum, or a friend who still buys records, can get from a link to a song playing without asking for help.

What's there now, and what I want to learn

The catalogue is small: a few hundred songs from around 15 artists. None of it is on Spotify, Apple Music or anywhere else. It only plays here. It's growing fast, but I'd rather be honest about the size than dress it up. This is an experiment, and the model matters more to me than the scale right now.

These are the questions I'm watching:

  • Do people who claim a player keep listening? A claim followed by one song and nothing else tells me the player needs work before anything else.
  • How long does it take to get from the link to a song playing? I'm asking everyone who tries it to tell me.
  • Do players get passed on? If people send them to friends outside crypto, and those friends use them, the onboarding works.
  • What do artists make of a public, per-play record? For some it'll be the best part. For others, publishing every play may raise questions about contracts and existing deals, and I want to hear those too.

There are plenty of things this doesn't solve yet. A few hundred songs isn't a replacement for a streaming library, and per-play payment doesn't fix discovery on its own. I'd rather find those limits with real listeners than guess at them.

Try it, then pass it on

The wall is at xtrata.xyz/players. It's free, and it takes a minute.

If you claim one, I'd love two things from you. First, tell me how long it took to get a song playing, and where you paused. Second, send a player to one person who loves music and has never touched any of this. Their experience is the one that counts.

Share with someone who loves music

Every play pays the artist. Pick a disc.

I'm Jim, the founder of Xtrata, so I'm not a neutral observer here. You can find me as @jimdotbtc on X.

Top comments (0)