DEV Community

Kapil Singhal
Kapil Singhal

Posted on Originally published at aranyix.tech

What your CSR committee should be able to see on any Tuesday

Most CSR plantation projects are reviewed twice: once when the budget is approved and once when the annual report is due. In between, the committee relies on whatever the implementing agency sends. That gap is where most of the hard questions come from later.

A simple test for CSR teams: pick an ordinary Tuesday, with no review meeting scheduled, and ask what the committee could see about a plantation project that day without emailing anyone. If the answer is "the last PDF the agency sent", the project is not being tracked. It is being reported on.

The four questions a committee actually asks

In most CSR reviews, the questions come back to four things:

  1. Where exactly is it? Not the village name, but the boundary or the points where saplings went in.
  2. How many are alive? Not how many were planted.
  3. What has been done since planting? Watering, fencing, gap-filling, and when.
  4. Does the money line up with the work? If a tranche was released for maintenance, is there maintenance on record in that period?

None of these needs a sophisticated system. Each needs a record made when the work happened, with a date and a location, that someone other than the agency can open.

What tracking looks like when it works

Planting day. Each plot or sapling is captured on site with GPS, a photo and a timestamp. Uploading photos from a phone gallery a week later is not the same thing. Location and time should come from the capture itself.

Resurveys on the same IDs. At 3, 6 and 12 months, the same plots are revisited and each record is updated: alive, dead, replaced. That's the only way a survival rate means something. A fresh headcount on a different sample does not tell you what happened to the trees you paid for.

Maintenance as entries, not narrative. "Regular maintenance was carried out" in a quarterly report tells a reviewer nothing. Dated entries tied to plots do.

Something between visits. Satellite and trend monitoring will not count saplings, but it will show if a site has been cleared, flooded or burnt between field rounds. That's often the first warning a committee gets.

A view the committee can open. A read-only dashboard or a standard export, available any day, not prepared for the meeting.

Where it usually breaks

In my experience the failure is rarely the planting. It's the handover between years. Agencies change, field staff change, spreadsheets get re-keyed, and the IDs from year one no longer match year two. By the time an impact assessment or an auditor asks for survival over time, nobody can join the records.

The fix is boring: one set of IDs from day one, one place the records live, and a resurvey calendar agreed in the MoU with the implementing agency rather than left to goodwill.

The money side

Most companies already track CSR spend well: approvals, tranches, utilisation certificates. What's missing is the link to outcomes. Under the Companies (CSR Policy) Rules, the board has to be satisfied that funds were used for the approved purpose, and ongoing projects run over several years. A tranche-by-tranche view that sits next to field evidence for the same period makes that sign-off much easier to stand behind.

You don't have to merge the two systems. You just need to be able to put them side by side for one project and one quarter.

A 90-day way to test this

If you are not sure whether your current setup is good enough, try it on one project:

  1. Pick a live plantation project with a known planting date.
  2. Recapture or import its planting records with locations.
  3. Run one resurvey within 90 days on the same IDs.
  4. Produce the committee view and compare it with the agency's last report.

If the two tell different stories, you've found the gap before an auditor does.

What to avoid

Be wary of any tool or vendor that promises to certify your outcomes, issue credits, or file with a regulator on your behalf. Good tracking produces evidence your team, auditors and assessors can review. The judgement stays with them.

I've written a longer buyer guide, with a 10-point checklist and a comparison table, here: CSR project tracking platform in India. If you run plantation CSR specifically, the CSR plantation monitoring platform page explains how we set up a 90-day pilot.


Kapil Singhal, Director, Axentis Technologies

aranyix.tech | axentis.tech

Aranyix on LinkedIn | Axentis Technologies on LinkedIn

Top comments (0)