More often than not, I see companies hire an SEO agency, a paid ads shop, a web development firm, an analytics vendor and a security or compliance firm.
On paper it looks like a specialized team. In practice it's five retainers, five account managers and a lot of finger pointing.
Most businesses don't need five agencies. They need one experienced person who knows how all of these channels and systems fit together, backed by AI agents that handle the repetitive work.
The Big Agency Handoff
During the sales process you meet the founders, the VPs and the senior strategists. Once the contract is signed, they move on to the next pitch and your account goes to a rotating team of junior staff juggling a dozen other clients.
You're paying a markup that covers office leases, middle management and sales commissions, and the people doing the work often have less experience than you do.
Problems with Multiple Agencies
Even when each agency is decent on its own, splitting the work means nobody owns the business outcome:
- SEO agency: chases traffic numbers, whether or not that traffic converts.
- Ad agency: spends the budget on clicks, then blames the landing pages or tracking when leads don't close.
- Web dev shop: builds the site without much thought for technical SEO, page speed, analytics tags or conversion rates.
- Design agency: hands over a nice Figma file that doesn't help generate demand.
You end up in the middle, sitting through weekly status calls trying to get four account managers to talk to each other.
Agencies You Can Consolidate
Here's what I typically replace:
| Agency Type | What I Handle Directly |
|---|---|
| Web Development & CMS | Custom WordPress and VIP, headless CMS builds with React and Next.js, Laravel, Webflow, Craft CMS and custom Stripe checkouts |
| SEO, AEO & Content | Technical SEO, schema and content built for both search and answer engine optimization, so you show up in AI search results |
| Analytics & Data | Google Tag Manager, server-side tracking, Meta Conversions API, GA4, and pipelines into BigQuery and Looker Studio |
| Paid Media, CRO & Demand Gen | Lead generation, conversion rate optimization, ad platform conversion signals, and HubSpot or Salesforce integration |
| Security, Privacy & Accessibility | Cloudflare WAF and bot protection, Core Web Vitals, GDPR and CCPA consent with Consent Mode v2, and WCAG remediation |
How AI Agents Fit In
I've done this work myself for years, and even before AI one experienced person beat the multi-agency setup because the strategy stayed in one head and nothing got lost in translation.
AI agents make it a lot more effective. I don't mean typing prompts into ChatGPT for generic blog posts. I mean custom agents and automation workflows for audits, code scaffolding, vulnerability scanning, data cleanup and search data analysis. Work that used to take a junior agency team three weeks now takes minutes, and I spend my time on the parts that need experience.
Experience Still Matters
AI doesn't replace experience. Give it to an inexperienced junior staffer and they'll produce bad work faster. They won't know why a server-side GTM container is dropping events, why a WordPress query is slowing down checkout, or why an ad campaign is wasting money. Knowing that is the job, and the agents handle everything around it.
Making the Case for One Person
The hardest part of this isn't the work. It's making it clear that one person can be a highly effective resource across this many agency services, and often a better one than the agencies themselves.
Most people hear "I do WordPress, SEO, analytics, ads, security and accessibility" and assume jack of all trades, master of none. That's a fair instinct. Plenty of freelancers list everything and do none of it well.
The difference is that these services aren't separate skills to me. They're parts of the same system:
- Tracking is code, so it lives in the site build.
- Technical SEO and AEO depend on how the site is built.
- Consent gating decides what analytics and ad platforms can see.
- Landing page speed and conversion rates decide how well ad spend performs.
Agencies split these up because that's how they staff, not because the work is actually separate. The best way I've found to make the case is to start with one real problem, like broken attribution or a slow checkout, fix it, and let the results show how far the rest of it reaches.
Benefits of One Consultant
- Lower cost: you pay for direct work, usually about half the monthly cost of an agency setup, without the overhead markup.
- No handoff: you work with the person doing the work, with no account manager in between.
- Everything connects: the ad, the landing page, the consent gating and the BigQuery reporting are built to work together from day one.
- Faster updates: changes that take three agencies a month of meetings and tickets ship in a few days.
If you want to cut down your agency roster, take a look at my digital growth consulting or get in touch.
Top comments (0)