Most commission problems don't announce themselves. The deposit arrives, the total looks about right, and the month closes. The loss, if there is one, sits inside the lines.
Here are five patterns worth knowing. None is exotic, and several have a legitimate version, which is what makes them hard. We're building Lapidar, a tool that checks statements against an agency's book. It isn't available yet, so this is about the problem, not a product.
This is written for property and casualty business. Life and health commissions have their own rules.
1. A chargeback that is wrong
A chargeback is commission the carrier takes back, usually because premium went back to the insured: a cancellation, an endorsement that lowers premium, an audit. Most are legitimate. The amount should normally equal the returned premium times the rate the commission was originally paid at.
It goes wrong when the rate differs from the original, when the return premium isn't the one on the cancellation, or when the event is not one you can find. A policy paid at 12% shouldn't be charged back at 15%.
Take an invented example: $500 returned premium, paid at 12%. The expected chargeback is $60. If the statement shows $75, that is $15 you will not notice unless you look at that line and know the original rate.
Chargebacks also arrive late. Audits happen after the term ends, and backdated cancellations can show up a month or more after you expect them. That is why a list of your own cancellations and premium-reducing changes helps: a negative line then matches something you already know about.
2. A commission paid twice, or a chargeback taken twice
Duplicates run in both directions. A carrier can pay the same commission on two statements, which feels like a gain until it is reversed later, sometimes months later, as a correction. Or a chargeback can appear on one statement and again on the next.
Neither shows up when you read one statement alone. You have to look across several months. The first kind is a surprise waiting to happen. The second is money you have to claim back.
3. The wrong rate
Commission is premium times rate, and the rate is where errors hide, because many statements don't print it. You divide commission by premium and compare the result with what you should have been paid.
"What you should have been paid" is itself not simple. Schedules change on effective dates. Renewals often pay less than new business. Different producers can have different splits, and a rewrite can reset the transaction type. A rate that looks wrong may be right under a schedule you forgot about, and one that looks fine may be a quiet cut.
The question to ask is whether the rate paid equals the schedule in force on the effective date. If you were told about a reduction, it is not an error. If you weren't, it is a question for the carrier.
4. Policies that aren't in your book
Some lines on a statement match nothing in your management system: a policy number you don't recognize, or a familiar insured under a new number. There are legitimate reasons. A renumbered policy, a transfer into your agency, a policy written outside your system.
There is also the reverse worry: policies you wrote that the carrier has no record of paying you for. Either way, the work is the same. Every statement line needs a home in your book, and unmatched lines need an explanation instead of a shrug. If they sit unexplained, you can't tell a harmless mismatch from money paid to the wrong place.
5. Renewals that never arrive
This one is invisible by construction. A missing renewal is not a wrong line. It is a line that isn't there, so nothing on the statement prompts you to look.
The reasons are usually ordinary: a changed policy number, an appointment or agency code that changed, a broker of record transfer, a lower premium base, an insured who paid late. Sometimes it is a carrier error. Working out which means starting from your book of policies renewing this month and checking each against the statement, rather than starting from the statement.
Because renewals recur, an unchecked one costs you again next year, and how far back you can claim depends on your agreement and sometimes state rules. We can't tell you the limit for your carrier.
What the five have in common
Each needs a comparison between two things that were never designed to be compared: the carrier's statement, in the carrier's format, and your own records, in yours. Each also has an innocent version, so a mismatch alone proves nothing. You have to find the cause before you can decide whether to raise it.
And none of it is hard in a single case. What makes it a real job is repetition: every carrier, every month, every policy, with the formats changing and PDFs dropping a sign now and then.
A reasonable starting point
If you do nothing else, keep your own list of cancellations and premium-reducing changes, note the rate each commission was paid at, and look at renewals from your book rather than from the statements. Those three habits turn several of the patterns above from invisible into visible. They won't cover everything, and they take time.
Reconciling every line against your book each month is the work we're building Lapidar to do.
Lapidar checks carrier commission statements against your book. To follow along, join the early access list at getlapidar.com.
Top comments (0)