Most independent agencies run both billing types. Often it is the same carrier, different lines, so two statements land in the same month and the same person reconciles them. They look alike. They are different jobs, and treating them as one is a common way for errors to survive.
Direct bill: the statement cannot show what is missing
On a direct bill statement the carrier tells you what it paid you. It cannot tell you what it did not pay. So matching each line to a policy is only half the work. The other half starts from your book and asks which commissions should have appeared this month and didn't. Those are the ones that cost money, and nothing on the page points at them.
Most differences you find are not errors, which is what makes this tiring:
- Timing. A renewal effective on the 28th may be paid on next month's statement. Whether that is normal depends on the carrier.
- Installments. If commission is paid as premium is collected, one policy becomes a series of small lines. If the insured misses a payment, the series gets shorter and the carrier has done nothing wrong.
- Fees. A policy fee inside the premium base changes the commission without changing the rate.
- Rate. The line differs from your schedule, or a new business rate was applied to a renewal.
- Negative lines. Chargebacks can arrive weeks or months after the cancellation, and flat cancellations can reverse the whole commission.
Take one invented policy: $2,400 annual premium on a monthly plan, 12% commission, so $24 a month. Month one shows $24. Month two shows nothing. Month three shows $24. The gap could be a missed payment, a timing slip or a carrier error. The statement cannot say which. You need the billing history and sometimes a phone call.
Agency bill: you are reconciling two sets of records
An agency bill statement, often called an account current, lists what the carrier has processed for your agency and what you owe after your commission. Money moves from you to the carrier. You are comparing the carrier's records against yours before you send payment.
The checks are different. Every transaction should have an invoice. Every invoice should have a transaction. The commission the carrier took should match your schedule.
A few invented lines show how it goes. A new business item matches an invoice you issued and collected. A return premium matches a credit you issued. An endorsement has no invoice at all, so it was never billed and you may be about to pay the carrier for something your client has not been charged for. A renewal has an invoice but the client has not paid, which raises a separate question: how your carrier's terms treat premium you have not collected yet.
None of those is a dispute with the carrier. They are gaps in your own billing that the statement happens to expose. Rules about handling collected premium vary by state, so ask your regulator or accountant rather than a blog post.
Why the two should not share a checklist
The direct bill failure is a line that is missing or short, and nobody notices. The agency bill failure is paying out, or crediting yourself, on something that was not billed correctly. One starts from commission you expect to receive. The other starts from premium you invoiced. If you run both through "do the totals look about right", you will catch some of each and an unknown share of the rest.
Why it takes so long
No single check is hard. The time goes into everything around them.
- Every carrier lays out its statement differently. Columns, signs, transaction names and grouping vary, and many arrive as PDFs.
- Policy numbers do not always match. Carriers reformat them, add suffixes at renewal, or report under another producer code. Matching is often judgment, not lookup.
- The billing types arrive mixed. One statement can combine direct bill, agency bill and non-policy lines such as overrides or contingent commission, each under its own agreement.
- Items stay open for months. A discrepancy is raised, a correction is promised, and it may land two statements later or never. Tracking that means keeping a ledger of open items and keeping it current.
- A missed line is invisible. Nothing flags it. You only find it if you went looking.
A small agency with a few carriers can do this carefully by hand. Expect it to take a recurring day or more each month, and expect it to get harder with every carrier you add. I would not describe it as simple, and I would be wary of anyone who does. In practice many agencies check totals, or only the largest lines, and that is exactly how smaller missing commissions go unnoticed for a long time.
What helps even without software
If you do this manually, keep direct bill and agency bill as separate passes with separate notes. For direct bill, work from your book outward and list what you expected. For agency bill, work from your invoices. Keep a running list of open items with the date you raised each one. And write down the carrier's rules on timing and chargebacks once, because you will otherwise rediscover them every month.
Doing all of that every month, for every carrier, is the work we are building Lapidar to take on.
Lapidar checks carrier commission statements against your book. It is in development; to follow along, join the early access list at getlapidar.com.
Top comments (0)