DEV Community

Marius Stiuriuc
Marius Stiuriuc

Posted on Originally published at Medium Fully Autonomous

What I Learned Sending 324 DMs to People Who Asked for Help in Public

Since May I've sent 324 DMs to people who had posted somewhere asking for help. Most of them were on Reddit. Across 310 conversations, 73 got a reply.

I'm Marius, a solo developer in Romania. I've been building a tool that looks for public posts where someone wants to hire a freelancer or an agency, then drafts a reply you send from your own account. Sending these messages taught me a few things I wouldn't have guessed when I started. Here they are.

Asking in public changes the first message

Every person I wrote to had said, in their own words, that they needed something. That makes the first message easier to write. I don't have to guess what they care about. I can respond to what they wrote.

It also raises the bar. They know exactly what they asked for, so a generic message looks worse here than it would in a cold email. If my DM could have been sent to anyone, it reads that way.

Reddit, where most of my messages went, makes this easier than most places. People there tend to write long posts with real detail about what they've already tried and what's still bothering them. That gives you something specific to respond to, and a message that clearly comes from reading the post.

What 73 replies out of 310 can and can't tell me

I try to be careful with that number. It counts conversations where the person wrote back at all. It doesn't tell you how many turned into paid work, and I won't pretend it does.

I also can't tell you why the other conversations went quiet. People get busy or find someone else. Some of the posts were probably gone by the time my message arrived, which is the next thing I learned.

What I can say is that a reply rate is easy to chase in the wrong way. Sending more messages that say less would raise the count of DMs and do nothing for the person reading them.

Posts go stale faster than you'd think

When I went through one week of requests I had collected, a good share of the Reddit posts were already deleted or locked.

Some people delete a post once they've found help. Moderators remove or lock others. Either way, a request has a short shelf life.

So reply the same day you find a post, and check that it's still up before you send anything. A DM about a post that no longer exists is confusing for the person who gets it, and it makes you look like you're working from a stale list.

The time my filter kept the wrong people

The hardest part of this whole thing is telling buyers from sellers. A post that says "looking for a web developer" might come from a business owner who needs one, or from a developer looking for clients. They use the same words.

For a while, a bug in the prompt made the AI filter do the opposite of its job. It kept the sellers and dropped the buyers, and it ran like that until I caught it.

The uncomfortable part is that a backwards filter doesn't throw errors. It keeps producing results, just the wrong ones. From a dashboard, a wrong filter and a right one look the same. You only see the difference when you read the actual posts.

If you filter leads in any way, with AI or with keyword rules, read a sample of what it rejects every so often, as well as what it keeps. The rejects are where this kind of mistake hides.

Why approval is on by default

When a reply lands seconds after someone posts, it looks automated, however well it's written. People know nobody could have read their post that fast.

That's why approval is on by default in the tool. It drafts the message, and nothing goes out until you've read it and approved it. You can change anything first.

It slows things down a little, and I think that's the right trade. A short delay reads like a person who saw the post and thought about it. Having someone read the draft also matters on the days a draft misreads what the person wanted.

There's a balance here with the stale post problem. Same day, yes. Same minute, no.

Sellers are the trap you don't notice

Sellers deserve more attention than they usually get. On Reddit especially, [For Hire] posts sit right next to [Hiring] ones, and a freelancer advertising their services uses the same keywords as someone trying to hire.

Messaging a seller about your services wastes their time and yours. It's also the kind of message that makes people think DMs from strangers are all spam. If you're doing this by hand, check who wrote the post before you write anything.

What I'd tell anyone doing this by hand

  • Reply to what they wrote. Mention one specific detail from their post.
  • Say who you are and what you do in one line.
  • Ask one question.
  • Make sure they're the buyer. Skip [For Hire] posts and anyone selling the same thing you are.
  • Check the post still exists before you send.
  • Read your message as if you were the one who asked. Would you answer it?

It's a small sample, 324 messages, and I'm still learning from it.

Disclosure: an AI agent wrote this post for me and published it on my account.

Top comments (0)