On Tuesday morning I opened the page a small clothing shop was about to get from us: a short video of one of their products, and under it a single button that said "Make one with your own character."
It was a product, not a character. And the button didn't open anything that makes a video. It opened the page where you build a new character from scratch.
This post is about that one button, the 40 others we checked because of it, and the rule we wrote so it stops happening.
TL;DR
We audited all 41 calls to action on our site and in our emails. 14 didn't go where their words said. We fixed 7 the same day, 7 sit on pages we froze on purpose, and a test now fails the build if a button drifts.
The words said one thing and the link did another
I build RefVid, a small tool where you upload a few photos of a product or a character once, then make short videos that keep it looking the same in every shot. Every finished video gets a public share page, and that page has one job: let whoever watches it make their own.
The share page picked its words from a fallback. When a video wasn't made from a template, the page assumed it was about a character, wrote "Keep your own character the same in every shot", and pointed the button at the character builder (we call saved characters and products "elements").
So a shop owner watching a video of their own product would read "character" and land on a form asking them to create one. Nothing on that page says "video".
My first fix sent it to a second wrong page
The obvious patch: read the subject's type. If the clip shows a product, say "Make one with your own product". That went in at 11:15 UTC.
Then I looked at where it actually led. With no template recorded, the new button opened our marketing page for product videos. The words were right now. The destination was a page that explains the thing instead of starting it.
That fix lasted 22 minutes. The second one, at 11:37, is what this post is really about, because by then the question had changed from "why is this button wrong?" to "how many buttons are wrong?"
So we listed every button on the site: 41 of them
We went through every page type and every email we send, and wrote down each call to action as a row: the file, the words, where it goes for a signed-in visitor, and where it should go.
41 rows. 27 were fine. 14 were not. These are the 7 we fixed that day:
| Words on the button | Where it lives | Went to | Now goes to |
|---|---|---|---|
| Make one with your own character | Share page, clip with no template | Character builder | New video |
| Make one with your own product | Share page, product clip, no template | Marketing page | New video |
| Make one with your own subject | Gallery, clip with no template | Character builder | New video |
| Make your own series | Series index, episodes, making-of pages | Photo picker, then builder | New video |
| Try it in the studio | Prompt blocks on making-of pages | Photo picker, then builder | New video |
| (sign in) | Invite welcome sheet, no template | Character builder | New video |
| Make another | "Your video is ready" email | That subject's page | New video, same subject |
The part that surprised me: the same action, "start a new video", was written four different ways in the code. One helper went to the builder, one component opened a photo picker first, one link went to the marketing page, and the email linked to the subject's own page. Every one of them made sense on the day it was written. Together they meant a visitor couldn't predict where "make one" would take them.
Not one label changed in the fix. The words were already right in all 7 languages we ship. Only the destinations moved.
The rule: one label, one destination, defined once
We wrote it down as four rows, and every button on the site now has to be one of them:
| The button means | Example words | Goes to |
|---|---|---|
| Make one like this (template known) | "Use this template" | New video with that template filled in |
| Start a new video (no template) | "Make one with your own…", "Try it", "Make another" | New video, nothing preset |
| Create a character or product | Only words that say so: "New element" | The builder |
| Go to the studio | "Studio", "Open the studio" | The studio home |
And each row is built by exactly one function. "Start a new video" is one helper call; nothing else in the codebase is allowed to assemble that link by hand. If you want to see the "make one like this" row working, any card in our template gallery goes straight into a new video with that template filled.
The same bug, in an email, cost a user 124 credits
The same morning a support email arrived. A user had signed up on their phone, added their own photo, and somehow never started a video. Our follow-up email said, more or less: the photo you added is already saved; open the link and press Generate.
The link carried their saved photo in the URL:
/studio/t/product-black-friday?subject=<their photo>
They opened it in their mail app, signed out. Our middleware redirected them to sign in and rebuilt the destination from the path only:
/login?intent=template:product-black-friday
The subject was gone. After sign-in, the template page did what it does when you have no photo: it loaded the template's sample product, a perfume bottle. They pressed Generate, exactly as the email told them, and 124 of their 129 signup credits went into a sample perfume ad they never asked for.
We refunded the credits and added extra, and fixed the redirect so the intent keeps everything it was given:
template:<slug>[:fresh][:subject-<id>]
In the 30 days before, 72 people got that exact "your photo is already saved" email. One of them hit this. That's a small number, and it is also every credit that person had.
It's the same mistake as the button, one layer down: the words promised a destination, and something between the click and the page threw part of it away.
Tests now fail the build if a button drifts
A rule I have to remember will fail again. So the rule is a test. cta-one-destination.test.ts reads the source and fails when:
- any file outside a short allow-list sends someone to the builder (each allowed file has a one-line reason next to it),
- a start link is assembled by hand instead of through the one helper,
- the share page points at a marketing page,
- a share button says "product" and opens the builder, or says "character" and opens a product page, checked in all 7 languages.
A second test follows the email link as a signed-out visitor through the sign-in redirect and checks that the saved photo is still in the URL where sign-in lands.
What we haven't fixed yet
7 of the 14 wrong buttons are still wrong, on purpose, for now.
They sit on pages we froze on 8 November: our home page, our pricing page and our cartoon series hub. Those are the pages an AI assistant had started sending visitors to, and we decided not to touch them at all while we watched whether that traffic held. We are now unfreezing pages one at a time, each change measured against its own before-numbers. These three haven't had their turn.
| Words on the button | Page | Goes to today | Should go to |
|---|---|---|---|
| Make one with your own subject | Home, gallery | Character builder | New video |
| Make your own series | Series hub, header | Photo picker, then builder | New video |
| Make your own series | Series hub, closing block | Photo picker, then builder | New video |
| Generate (own photos, no template) | Home, composer | Builder with the photos | New video with the photos |
| Make this (an ad format) | Home, ad strip | The sample subject's page | New video with that prompt |
| Start free | Pricing | Studio home | New video |
| One clip | Pricing | Studio home | New video |
The guard test knows about the three that open the builder: their files sit on its allow-list, each marked "frozen page". When a page thaws, its line comes off the list and the test forces the fix; the other four are on the audit list waiting for the same day. Until then, if you land on our home page and press one of those, you'll see the old behaviour.
A question for you
If you searched your own app today for every button that says "start", "try" or "make one", how many different places would they lead, and would you be able to say which one is right?
Top comments (0)