DEV Community

Cover image for Who controls you more: your government or your feed?
Saifuddin Ahmed
Saifuddin Ahmed

Posted on

Who controls you more: your government or your feed?

There are two ways to change what millions of people think and do.

The first is old and loud. A government switches off the internet. In 2024, according to Access Now and the #KeepItOn coalition, governments and other actors imposed 296 internet shutdowns in 54 countries, the worst year on record (Access Now, 2025). Everyone notices. People complain, find a VPN, wait, and remember.

The second is new and quiet. A ranking system decides which of a thousand posts you see first. Nobody switches anything off. In 2014, researchers published an experiment in which Facebook adjusted the emotional content of the News Feed for 689,003 users for one week, and those users' own posts shifted slightly in the same emotional direction (Kramer, Guillory & Hancock, PNAS 2014). Almost nobody noticed. That was the point.

So here is the question I want to put on the table: which of these two has more power over your daily life?

The case for the state

States still hold the hardest kinds of power: police, prisons, borders, currency, and, increasingly, the kill switch for the network itself. A feed can nudge your mood; a government can take your phone at a checkpoint. When the internet goes dark in a conflict zone, no algorithm brings it back.

Anyone who says "governments do not matter anymore, only platforms do" has probably never lived through a shutdown.

The case for the algorithm

But a shutdown is visible, and visible power produces resistance. Ranking systems work differently:

  • They are invisible. You do not see the posts you were not shown.
  • They are personal. Each person gets a slightly different reality, so there is no shared event to resist.
  • They are continuous. Not one decision a year, but millions per second, each one small enough to seem harmless.
  • They are welcomed. We open the app ourselves, many times a day.

Power that you invite into your pocket and thank for its convenience is a very different kind of power.

An engineer's answer: it is not who controls you, it is whether you have memory

I trained as a control engineer, and I keep seeing society as a feedback loop. I wrote about this in Arabic as a society without an integral term: a hotel shower where the water arrives late, so you keep correcting too hard, swinging between burning and freezing.

Feeds are tuned for exactly that swing: react fast, react strongly, forget, react again. The missing piece in that loop, what engineers call the integral term, is simply memory: the slow accumulation of what actually happened, that stops the system from overreacting to every new signal.

Both governments and algorithms are easier to resist for people with memory: people who read long things, keep notes, remember last month's outrage before joining this week's.

A practical answer: decide where the tool lives

The Amish are often described as people who reject technology. They did not reject the telephone. As sociologist Donald Kraybill described, many communities kept it out of the house, in a shared booth at the end of the road. They took the tool and changed its place. I wrote about that in how to use technology without it using you.

That is the most realistic defense most of us have, against either kind of control:

  1. Give the feed a place, not your whole day. One app off the home screen. Notifications off by default.
  2. Choose chronological or followed-only views wherever a platform allows it.
  3. Keep one source of slow information: books, long articles, a newsletter you chose.
  4. Prepare for the loud kind too: offline maps, a downloaded copy of what matters, apps that work without a connection. (This is one reason I build software that works offline first.)

I explore the quieter kind of control at more length in an open research paper, in Arabic: Moral Desertification and Liquid Knowledge in the Algorithmic Age. It asks what happens to how values are learned when the feed, not the family or the school, decides what a child sees next.

I'm Saifuddin Ahmed, a control engineer turned software builder and the founder of Ishraqa Daily, a community on Google Play, the App Store and the Microsoft Store that turns knowledge into impact: developer clubs where people build open-source projects with mentors, languages, reading and listening together, and scholarships and opportunities. I also built Rafu and founded OtwoX Digital Solutions. More of my work is at saifuddin.dev and on LinkedIn.


I drafted this piece with an AI writing assistant. The ideas come from my own essays and experience, and the questions are the ones I am still thinking about.

Top comments (0)