Building a Decision-Tree Algorithm: When to Implement Dementia Home Care Systems

Tags: #algorithms #healthtech #decisiontrees #machinelearning #healthcare

As developers, we often build systems to help users make complex decisions. But what happens when the decision involves something as nuanced as dementia care? This article explores how to approach building decision-support systems for healthcare scenarios, using dementia home care as a case study.

The Problem: Non-Linear Decision Complexity

Traditional if-else logic breaks down when dealing with healthcare decisions. Dementia care needs don't follow a predictable linear progression—they change in unpredictable jumps, creating a complex state management problem.

// Oversimplified approach (doesn't work well)
function getCareLevel(memoryScore) {
  if (memoryScore > 80) return "independent";
  if (memoryScore > 60) return "supervised";
  return "assisted";
}

Real-world healthcare decisions require multidimensional analysis:

// Better approach: Multi-factor assessment
class DementiaAssessment {
  constructor(factors) {
    this.cognitiveState = factors.cognitive;
    this.physicalSafety = factors.safety;
    this.behavioralChanges = factors.behavioral;
    this.caregiverBurnout = factors.caregiver;
    this.medicalComplexity = factors.medical;
  }

  calculateRiskScore() {
    return {
      wanderingRisk: this.assessWandering(),
      kitchenSafety: this.assessKitchenSafety(),
      fallRisk: this.assessFallRisk(),
      medicationErrors: this.assessMedication(),
      caregiverStress: this.assessCaregiverBurnout()
    };
  }
}

Implementing Progressive Care Staging

Healthcare systems often use staging algorithms. Here's how you might model dementia care progression:

const CARE_STAGES = {
  EARLY: {
    level: 1,
    services: ['companionship', 'medication_reminders', 'light_housekeeping'],
    hours_per_week: 8,
    cost_range: [280, 296] // CAD per week
  },

  MIDDLE: {
    level: 2,
    services: ['personal_care', 'behavioral_management', 'safety_monitoring'],
    hours_per_week: 20,
    cost_range: [740, 780]
  },

  LATE: {
    level: 3,
    services: ['round_the_clock', 'medical_support', 'mobility_assistance'],
    hours_per_week: 168, // 24/7
    cost_range: [3150, 3276] // Live-in care
  }
};

function determineStage(assessmentData) {
  const riskFactors = new DementiaAssessment(assessmentData).calculateRiskScore();

  // Critical safety triggers
  if (riskFactors.wanderingRisk || riskFactors.kitchenSafety === 'high') {
    return CARE_STAGES.MIDDLE;
  }

  // Caregiver system failure
  if (riskFactors.caregiverStress > 0.8) {
    return CARE_STAGES.MIDDLE;
  }

  return CARE_STAGES.EARLY;
}

Building Cost-Optimization Algorithms

Healthcare systems need cost optimization. Here's a simple algorithm for care planning:

class CareOptimizer {
  constructor(location = 'montreal') {
    this.rates = {
      companion: { min: 35, max: 37 },
      personal: { min: 37, max: 39 },
      specialized: { min: 37, max: 39 },
      live_in: 450 // per day
    };

    this.taxCredits = {
      federal: 0.15, // Medical expense tax credit
      quebec: 0.20   // Home support tax credit
    };
  }

  calculateOptimalPlan(needs, budget) {
    const plans = this.generatePlans(needs);
    return plans
      .map(plan => ({
        ...plan,
        effectiveCost: this.calculateEffectiveCost(plan.cost),
        riskMitigation: this.assessRisk(plan.services)
      }))
      .filter(plan => plan.effectiveCost <= budget)
      .sort((a, b) => b.riskMitigation - a.riskMitigation)[0];
  }

  calculateEffectiveCost(grossCost) {
    const totalCredits = this.taxCredits.federal + this.taxCredits.quebec;
    return grossCost * (1 - totalCredits);
  }
}

Integration with Public APIs

Montreal has public healthcare APIs. Here's how you might integrate:

class MontrealHealthcareAPI {
  constructor() {
    this.endpoints = {
      clsc: 'https://api.santemontreal.qc.ca/clsc',
      alzheimer: 'https://api.alzheimermontreal.ca/resources',
      dayPrograms: 'https://api.ville.montreal.qc.ca/community-programs'
    };
  }

  async getAvailableServices(postalCode) {
    try {
      const [clscServices, alzheimerPrograms, dayPrograms] = await Promise.all([
        this.fetchCLSCServices(postalCode),
        this.fetchAlzheimerServices(),
        this.fetchDayPrograms(postalCode)
      ]);

      return {
        publicCare: clscServices,
        support: alzheimerPrograms,
        programs: dayPrograms,
        waitTimes: this.estimateWaitTimes(clscServices)
      };
    } catch (error) {
      console.error('API integration failed:', error);
      return this.getFallbackResources();
    }
  }
}

Key Implementation Considerations

State Management: Healthcare needs are stateful and time-dependent. Consider using state machines:

const careStateMachine = {
  independent: ['supervised', 'crisis'],
  supervised: ['assisted', 'independent', 'crisis'], 
  assisted: ['supervised', 'crisis'],
  crisis: ['assisted', 'facility_care']
};

Error Handling: Healthcare systems require robust error handling and fallback mechanisms.

Privacy: Implement proper data encryption and comply with healthcare privacy regulations.

Scalability: Design for multiple users and real-time updates.

Practical Takeaways

1. Multi-factor Analysis: Healthcare decisions require analyzing multiple variables simultaneously
2. Progressive Enhancement: Start with basic functionality and add complexity gradually
3. Cost Optimization: Include financial algorithms in healthcare decision systems
4. API Integration: Leverage public healthcare APIs where available
5. State Management: Use state machines for complex healthcare progressions

Building healthcare decision-support systems requires balancing algorithmic complexity with real-world usability. The goal isn't to replace human judgment, but to provide data-driven insights that help families make informed decisions.

---

This technical exploration was inspired by real healthcare challenges. For actual medical decisions, always consult healthcare professionals.