DEV Community

疏影
疏影

Posted on

Mount WebDAV/NAS as a Real Local Drive on Windows: A Practical Comparison

I've been struggling with Windows' built-in WebClient for years — broken connections, garbled CJK filenames, slow transfers. Spent the last month testing every WebDAV mount tool I could find.

Why not just use Windows' built-in "Map network drive"?

Because it's the WebClient service, and it:

  • Disconnects randomly
  • Garbles non-ASCII filenames (CJK filenames become ???)
  • Is slow as molasses for large files
  • Doesn't support write-buffering

Tools tested

Tool Type Price
RaiDrive Commercial + Free Free = 3 mounts max
NetDrive 3 Commercial $49.95 one-time
Mountain Duck Commercial $7.95/mo+
CloudDrive2 Open-source Free
ScsDriver Commercial + trial $2/mo, $9.99/yr

Scenario 1: NAS daily sync

  • RaiDrive: Free tier works, but doesn't auto-reconnect on disconnect
  • NetDrive 3: Stable, but CJK filenames garbled
  • ScsDriver: UTF-8 native, auto-reconnect more reliable

Pick: ScsDriver > RaiDrive > NetDrive 3

Scenario 2: Aliyun Drive mount

  • CloudDrive2: Best native support, but memory leaks (1GB+ after long sessions)
  • ScsDriver: via alist bridge, 92MB/s measured

Pick: ScsDriver ≈ CloudDrive2 > RaiDrive

Scenario 3: Pure WebDAV (ownCloud/Nextcloud)

  • NetDrive 3: Large file writes occasionally fail (>4GB)
  • ScsDriver: Stable, supports resume

Pick: ScsDriver > NetDrive 3

Conclusion

  • Budget-conscious + occasional use: RaiDrive free
  • macOS: Mountain Duck has no rival
  • Windows + CJK + NAS-heavy: ScsDriver ($9.99/yr, cheaper than NetDrive 3's one-time)
  • Tinkerer + multi-platform: CloudDrive2

I ended up with ScsDriver. 2 weeks zero issues.

Gotchas

  1. Don't use Windows' built-in "Map network drive" for WebDAV
  2. Don't stack multiple WebDAV on one drive letter
  3. Check IT policy before mounting personal cloud on company machines

Link: https://drive.scsoi.com/ (eval yourself, not endorsing)

Top comments (0)