On Friday, November 13, Los Angeles hosted the first AI Music Awards. It was organized by the Sonic Intelligence Academy, a young company that makes AI music charts and tools for spotting AI-made songs. According to Reuters, the big winner was Xania Monet, an AI-generated avatar who took artist, song and album of the year.
I read the coverage expecting a story about AI failing on stage. That isn't what happened, and that's why I'm writing about it.
What actually went wrong
Variety's Corbin Bolies was in the room, and his report reads like a postmortem written by someone trying hard not to laugh:
- The show started about 30 minutes late and finished almost 40 minutes behind schedule.
- A film trailer didn't play on cue. When it finally did, it cut off before the actor appeared.
- The hosts introduced presenters, then announced a commercial break, and one award ended up delayed by 13 minutes.
- A sponsor's ad played at a random moment.
- Nominee introductions were dropped, so winners were simply announced.
- The crowd thinned as the night went on.
Then there are the parts that sound made up. An AI correspondent sat in a tall white faux-stone vessel and couldn't do the red carpet, because it couldn't move. Several human performers lip-synced to AI-generated tracks, and Variety says two acts mimed their entire sets.
We spent the last few years worrying that robots would replace singers. At the first ceremony for robot music, singers were miming for the robots.
The lesson I'd steal from it
Look at that list again. None of it is a model hallucinating or a generator producing garbage. It's a teleprompter, video cues, a run of show and timing.
I've been building software for 15+ years, first as a developer, then as tech lead and now as team lead. I've shipped worse than a late trailer. What I keep relearning is that the clever part of a launch rarely fails. The new algorithm, the shiny integration, the thing everyone was nervous about usually works, because everyone was nervous about it and tested it twice.
What fails is the part nobody owned: who presses play, what happens if the video doesn't load, who decides to skip a segment when you're 30 minutes behind. That's not tech. It's a rehearsal and a checklist.
If you run launches, demos or company events, here's the boring version:
- Do one full dress rehearsal, in order, with the real hardware.
- Give every cue an owner. One name per video, slide and transition.
- Write a "we're late" plan before you're late. What gets cut first?
- Have a fallback for every screen moment. If the video won't play, what does the host say?
None of that needs AI. All of it would have saved this show.
So is it real music?
This is where I'm genuinely torn.
The winners argue it is. Reuters quotes producer Drake Murphy: "In a world where everybody calls AI fake, the human behind it is real." Telisha "Nikki" Jones, who created Xania Monet, says she wrote all the lyrics and then set them to music with AI. Billboard reportedly counted the song as the first by an AI-based act on one of its radio charts.
The other side is just as real. Record labels have sued AI companies over training on copyrighted songs. Many musicians worry that a flood of cheap AI tracks makes it harder for human artists to be heard, and takes paid work away from session singers, producers and engineers.
My moderate take: if a person writes the words, picks the sound and puts in the hours, there's craft in it. I wouldn't call it fake. But I'd want it labeled, the same way I'd want to know whether a photo was edited. And I'd like the people whose music trained these tools to get paid.
The organizers say there will be a next year, and that they'll fix the technical issues. I hope they rehearse.
Your turn: if a human wrote the lyrics and AI made the music, would you count it as real music? Why?
Top comments (0)