DEV Community

Serguey Shinder
Serguey Shinder

Posted on

Our Quote Conversion Rate Was Eighteen Percent Because Every Revised Quote Counted as One We Had Lost

Our larger branches employ estimators who price bigger jobs, such as an extension, a barn conversion or a small development of houses, and send the builder a quote. The sales director's dashboard shows how many quotes become orders. Across the company the figure was eighteen percent. At our busiest estimating branch it was nine, and a course on closing sales was being booked for its estimators.

An analyst on my team took one customer from that branch to see what a lost quote looked like. He was a self builder whose house had been quoted seven times in three months. Each time the architect changed the plans, the estimator copied the quote into a new one, because our trading system does not allow a quote to be edited once it has been sent. The six earlier versions were left to expire after thirty days. The dashboard counted one order and six lost quotes.

The busiest branch looked worst because it did the most careful work. It priced the largest jobs, whose plans change most, and its estimators revised quotes whenever a builder asked. A branch that quoted once and never followed up looked better.

We grouped quotes into jobs, using the customer and the site address, and counted a job as won if any version became an order. The company figure rose to forty one percent. The busiest branch came to forty seven, the best in the business. The course was cancelled.

A quote now has a field that says which earlier quote it replaces, filled in automatically when an estimator copies one, and a replaced quote is closed as superseded rather than left to expire. Every quote ends in one of four states: won, lost with a reason, superseded, or expired without a reply. The dashboard counts jobs, and the reasons for genuinely lost jobs, mostly price and timing, now go to the buyers every month.

The first version of the report was not wrong about its data. Every quote it counted existed and most of them had expired. It counted documents, because documents were what the system stored, and the business wanted to know about jobs. When a figure is going to be used to judge people, check that each thing it counts is the thing the business means.

– Serguey Shinder

Top comments (0)