The rhythm guitar
was recorded once,
and it was a good take.
You wanted it wide.
The big kind of rhythm sound,
one guitar in each speaker,
the chorus filling the room.
So you duplicated the track,
panned one copy hard left,
the other hard right,
and pressed play.
It was louder.
It was not wider.
The guitar sat
exactly where it had been,
in the middle,
between the speakers.
Nothing was broken.
You had built
a centre.
Your ears decide
where a sound is
by comparing what reaches each of them.
Louder on the left,
or a little earlier on the left,
and it is on the left.
Two speakers playing
the exact same signal,
at the exact same level,
at the exact same time,
give your ears nothing to compare.
The only place
one source could be
to sound like that
is straight ahead.
So that is where you hear it.
It is the same trick
that puts the lead vocal
in the middle of a mix
with no centre speaker at all.
Panning a copy hard left
and its twin hard right
is just panning it to the centre
the long way round,
plus a few decibels.
What makes a double tracked guitar wide
is that it is not a copy.
The player
plays the part again.
The second take
is a few milliseconds early here,
a little late there,
a fraction sharp on one chord,
picked slightly harder on another.
Those differences
keep changing,
so your ears cannot fuse the two
into one guitar in the middle.
They hear two players,
one on each side.
So play it twice.
Same part,
same sound,
a real second performance.
Tight,
but not perfect,
because perfect
would put you back in the centre.
Then pan them apart.
If there is no second take,
there are ways to fake it.
Abbey Road built a way
in 1966,
artificial double tracking,
because John Lennon
hated singing everything twice.
A slowly wandering delay,
a small pitch shift,
a different amp sound on the copy.
They help.
None of them is as wide
as playing it again.
And whatever you do,
press the mono button afterwards.
A copy
nudged a few milliseconds late
can sound wide in stereo
and thin and hollow
when the two sides are added together.
Real takes
survive that better,
because their differences
never line up long enough
to cancel.
Width is not
two speakers playing.
It is two speakers
disagreeing a little.
– Serguey Asael Shinder
Top comments (0)