DEV Community

Cover image for Shut the Box Strategy Chart: Exact Small-Board Choices
The Little Dice Club
The Little Dice Club

Posted on Originally published at shutthebox.cc

Shut the Box Strategy Chart: Exact Small-Board Choices

By The Little Dice Club

Two dice sit in a wooden tray with blank hinged tiles beside a pencil and an unfilled worksheet.

This Shut the Box strategy chart maximizes the chance of closing every remaining tile. It covers specific small boards, not every position, minimum expected score, or multiplayer targets. The percentages include later rolls and the best subsequent choices for this objective.

Key takeaways

  • Match the complete open board, not merely the roll.
  • The mandatory one-die switch changes the calculation.
  • Finishing probabilities differ from next-roll survival odds.

Rules and assumptions

Under the website's rules, close one or more open tiles summing exactly to the roll. Closed tiles stay closed. No matching combination ends the turn; an empty board scores zero.

Use two fair six-sided dice while any open tile exceeds 6, then one die whenever all open tiles are 6 or lower. The threshold concerns the highest tile, not the remaining sum. Rolls are independent; there is no optional stopping. Other house rules require different calculations.

Chart: only 1, 2, 3, and 4 open

You must use one die. The last column is the probability of eventually reaching zero after making the listed closure, assuming optimal subsequent choices for finishing. It is not the probability of rolling the current result, which has already happened.

Roll Best closure Tiles left Chance of reaching zero
1 1 2, 3, 4 13.89%
2 2 1, 3, 4 11.11%
3 3 1, 2, 4 19.44%
4 4 1, 2, 3 33.33%
5 1+4 or 2+3 2, 3 or 1, 4 22.22%
6 2+4 1, 3 22.22%

Source: original exact enumeration, November 20, 2026. Percentages are rounded; exact fractions and the calculation script are retained with the research record.

The two choices on 5 tie. On 6, closing 1+2+3 is legal but leaves only 4, requiring a 4 next: probability 1/6. Closing 2+4 leaves {1,3}, which finishes with probability 2/9, so the chart prefers it.

Verify a result by hand

With {1,3} open, one die gives three useful first outcomes:

  • Roll 4: close both and finish.
  • Roll 1: close 1, then finish only by rolling 3.
  • Roll 3: close 3, then finish only by rolling 1.

Other outcomes fail. Therefore the finishing probability is 1/6 + (1/6 × 1/6) + (1/6 × 1/6) = 2/9, about 22.22%.

Next-roll survival is 3/6, or 50%, because three faces permit a move. Finishing is less likely because some successful first rolls still need another favorable outcome.

Worked decision: open 1, 2, 3, 4, 7; roll 7

The 7 requires two dice before this roll. Exactly three closures match:

Close Tiles left Next dice Chance of reaching zero
7 1, 2, 3, 4 One die 20.37%
3+4 1, 2, 7 Two dice 17.59%
1+2+4 3, 7 Two dice 12.04%

Each leaves a sum of ten, but closing 7 gives the highest finishing chance: 11/54 versus 19/108 and 13/108. The calculation includes the dice switch. Additional open tiles would change the available closures and results.

How future choices are evaluated

The model assigns success probability 1 to an empty board. For another board, it lists every dice outcome and every matching nonempty tile subset. For each outcome, it selects the closure leaving the highest finishing probability; no legal closure contributes zero. It then averages those results using the dice probabilities.

Every move removes tiles, so smaller-board results determine larger ones. Exact fractions avoid intermediate rounding. This establishes optimal choices only for the stated objective and rules. Compare the general strategy guide before applying a chart to another version of the game.

Top comments (0)