DEV Community

How to eliminate if-else chain, for long life software

Sameh Muhammed on October 10, 2022

Motivation All programing principles and paradigms aim to enhance code readability and maintainability, from OOP to functional, SOLID, D...

Read full post

Jean-Michel 🕵🏻‍♂️ Fayard • Oct 11 '22

Agree with all your points.

Language specific, but in Kotlin the when expression is a massive improvment over if/else

val message = when (x) {
    in 1..10 -> "x is in the range"
    in validNumbers -> "x is valid"
    !in 10..20 -> "x is outside the range"
    else -> "none of the above"
}
println("validate($x): $message")

Sameh Muhammed • Oct 11 '22

Yes, good tip but i don't use Kotlin that much, it's language specific but the idea is to make code more readable.

Jean-Michel 🕵🏻‍♂️ Fayard • Oct 11 '22

I wonder what other languages have a similarly good structure.
Not like switch case which don't return anything, something better.
Probably functional languages in general?

Mario Santini • Oct 11 '22

Like switch expressions for Java v12 have a look

Jean-Michel 🕵🏻‍♂️ Fayard • Oct 11 '22

indeed yes, I didn't know they can return a value

Patrick Elsen • Oct 11 '22

Rust has a nice match statement too, even though it is not functional.

match person {
    Person::Employee(employee) if employee.years() > 3 => true,
    Person::Employee(employee) if employee.age() >63 => true,
    Person::Intern(internet) if intern.name().first() == 'S' => true,
    _ => false
}

I believe it is something that most functional language have and newer languages are starting to adopt it.

Ben Sinclair • Oct 19 '22

Just a heads up that the Markdown we use here supports syntax highlighting, and is generally more accessible than inserting an image of code. Images of text are an issue for people using screen readers, for example, and their content won't get picked up by the site's search facility.

You can add code blocks with 3 backticks: More details in our editor guide!

Sameh Muhammed • Oct 19 '22

Thanks! , great idea

Robert • Oct 12 '22

I would say be aware of polymorphism. It's not wrong, but not the only concept.
The principle composition over inheritance is often a better choice, because you don't couple classes with an inheritance structure.
Sometimes it's a great mix to use inheritance for the structure and composition for the logic.

peerreynders • Oct 12 '22

Sometimes it's a great mix to use inheritance for the structure and composition for the logic.

i.e. prefer interface inheritance (implements; for polymorphism) over implementation inheritance (extends).

The original quote (GoF, 1994, p.20):

Favour object composition over class inheritance

talks about implementation inheritance.

Sameh Muhammed • Oct 12 '22

Actually, we talked about this principle here Composition vs Inheritance, take a look 😉

Juan Vega • Oct 14 '22

Good post.

Just to add something, there is another possible iteration when you have a set of fixed conditions (like the switch), for large number of options a map is a better and more readable approach.

Kacper Turowski • Oct 11 '22

I am SOOOO HAPPY to see your article. For once it's "how to do it better" and not "omigosh, you should NEVER nest if-s, here's why". Glad to see people who don't clickbait.