DEV Community

Discussion on: If the World Wide Web were re-created today with no legacy dependencies, how would it be different?

Collapse
 
stegriff profile image
Ste Griffiths

Tim BL always said that he regretted making URLs complicated (scheme, domains, and path) and not fully hierarchical. That if he were to get a do-over, instead of https://dev.to/ben/post we would have https/to/dev/ben/post. Just thought I'd throw that in as an interesting fact :)

Collapse
 
nektro profile image
Meghan (she/her) • Edited

I don't like https/to/dev/ben/post because it removes the at-a-glance organization of why URLs are structured that way.

However, that said, I would reverse domain names and prefer https:/to.dev/ben/post

The parts of a URI are immediately identifiable from just looking at them.

  • Scheme: Application-layer communication protocol we are using
  • Host: Location of the server we are contacting
  • Path/Query: The document/page we are requesting
Collapse
 
ben profile image
Ben Halpern

The cultural nature of domains as we know them today makes this such an odd thing to think about. ".com" is such a thing.

Collapse
 
vuild profile image
Vuild

IT was so hard to get..

Browser = Window to Internet
Aol is not Internet
Something.anything else would just collapse (ppl, products, links everywhere) so .com was it.
The numbers: 3/4 letter speakable .com is v rare. Companies/brands/ppl/things not.
Type in traffic (autocompletion for example is usually .com).
Age/authenticity/credibility/income generating appreciating assets.

Even in 2000, ppl were saying "it's so hard to find a good domain".

It's better now.

I have .coms & people 'respect/trust' it more (I don't really care, but it's prized). Also, native per country (.fr, ..de etc).

google.co.ck nsfw (that tag is not really gonna work in this instance, but hey, it's a legit domain).

Internet today? Big set of gates with a {hired} famous person smiling & asking for your credit card + two forms of identity, a signing of a TOS before you can enter & get your @internet handle. 9-6 operating hours. WWW would be a 'room' for select credentialed professionals. Read only.

Collapse
 
vuild profile image
Vuild

That is interesting. I prefer the way we have it, mostly.