Let me guess: someone in a meeting said "Why don't we just create a page for every possible keyword combination?" and here you are, Googling whether this is genius or career suicide.
The answer is yes.
Programmatic SEO—generating thousands of landing pages using templates and data—can work spectacularly well. Zillow has millions of pages. Tripadvisor has millions more. Nomad List built an entire business model on it. But for every success story, there are dozens of sites that got slapped with manual actions or simply created 50,000 pages that nobody visits and Google doesn't care about.
I've watched companies generate 100,000 pages in a weekend and celebrate. Then watched them scramble to delete 90,000 of them three months later when traffic never materialized and their crawl budget imploded.
Here's what actually works when you're trying to scale programmatic SEO in 2025, when AI makes it easier than ever to create pages—and easier than ever to create a spectacular mess.
The Fundamental Question Nobody Asks
Before you generate your first page, answer this: Does each page serve a genuine search intent?
Not "could someone theoretically search for this." Not "this keyword has 10 searches per month." But: Would a human landing on this page find something valuable that they couldn't find more easily elsewhere?
Because here's the thing—Google's gotten pretty good at spotting programmatic content. The November 2024 core update specifically targeted thin, templated pages that existed purely for SEO. Sites lost 60-80% of their traffic overnight.
The difference between sites that survived and sites that tanked? Value per page.
Zillow's page for "homes for sale in Austin, TX" has actual listings, real data, market trends, and neighborhood information. It's not just a template with "Austin" swapped in. Someone searching for that exact thing gets exactly what they need.
Meanwhile, "best coffee shops in Austin for remote workers who like oat milk" might technically be a searchable phrase, but if your page is just a template with generic text... you're building on sand.
The Data Layer Makes or Breaks Everything
You can't fake your way through programmatic SEO with good templates. The templates are actually the easy part.
What separates useful programmatic pages from spam is the underlying data. Rich, specific, regularly updated data that gives each page a reason to exist.
G2 does this brilliantly. Their comparison pages ("Salesforce vs HubSpot") work because they have actual user reviews, feature comparisons, pricing data, and integration information. The template is simple. The data is comprehensive.
Your data layer needs:
Unique attributes per page. Not just swapping city names. Real differentiating information that changes the value proposition of each page. If you're building location pages, you need actual local data—demographics, specific businesses, local statistics, real photos. Generic stock images of people pointing at laptops don't count.
Quantitative information. Numbers, statistics, counts, measurements. These give AI something concrete to work with beyond just rephrasing the same generic content. "15 coffee shops" is more useful than "several coffee shops."
Structured relationships. How entities connect to each other. Products to categories. Locations to services. Features to benefits. These relationships let you create genuinely different content for each page variation.
Update mechanisms. Static data from 2023 isn't going to cut it. You need systems to refresh information, add new entries, remove outdated items. Programmatic SEO isn't a one-time generation—it's an ongoing maintenance operation.
I've seen companies spend $50K on AI content generation and $500 on data infrastructure. Then they wonder why their pages feel thin. Wrong investment ratio.
Template Architecture That Scales
Your template structure needs to balance consistency (for efficiency) with variation (for uniqueness). Too much consistency and every page looks identical. Too much variation and you can't maintain it.
Here's what works:
Modular sections with conditional logic. Not every page needs every section. If you don't have pricing data for a product, don't include a pricing section with "Contact us for pricing" (everyone can smell that cop-out). Show the sections where you have real information.
Multiple template variants. Not one template for all 10,000 pages. Maybe 5-10 templates based on data richness, page type, or user intent. Your high-volume, data-rich pages can be more complex. Your long-tail pages might be simpler but still valuable.
Dynamic content blocks that pull from different data sources. User reviews here, technical specs there, related products below. Each block independently populated based on what's available.
Fallback hierarchies. If you don't have local data, can you show regional data? If you don't have recent reviews, can you show older ones with a timestamp? Graceful degradation beats empty sections.
Nomad List's city pages are a masterclass in this. Every city page has the same general structure, but the content blocks appear or disappear based on available data. Cities with lots of information get rich, detailed pages. Smaller cities get simpler but still useful pages. Nothing feels artificially padded.
Using AI Without Creating AI Slop
Look, we all know you're using AI to generate content at this scale. Google knows it too. The question isn't whether you're using AI—it's whether you're using it responsibly.
The AI content that gets penalized shares common characteristics: repetitive phrasing, generic observations, obvious template patterns, lack of specific details, and that distinctive "AI voice" that sounds confident about nothing in particular.
Here's how to use AI for programmatic content without triggering quality alarms:
Feed it specific data, not generic prompts. "Write about coffee shops in Austin" produces generic slop. "Here are 23 coffee shops in Austin with their addresses, hours, wifi speed tests, seating capacity, and customer ratings—create a comprehensive guide" produces something potentially useful.
Use AI for structure and synthesis, not invention. Let it organize information, identify patterns, create summaries. Don't let it make up facts or hallucinate details. Every claim should trace back to your data layer.
Implement variation at the prompt level. Don't use the exact same prompt for all 10,000 pages. Create prompt templates with variables, randomized structures, different angles. You want consistency in quality, not consistency in phrasing.
Post-generation quality filters. Check for repetitive phrases across pages. Flag pages below a certain uniqueness threshold. Identify pages that are too similar to each other. I've seen companies use AI to generate content, then use different AI to check quality. It's AI all the way down, but it works.
Human review for high-value pages. You can't manually review 10,000 pages. But you can review the top 100 by expected traffic. Polish those. Make them genuinely great. Let the long tail be good enough, but make your head terms exceptional.
The programmatic SEO strategies I've seen work in 2025 treat AI as a scaling tool for human expertise, not a replacement for it. You still need someone who understands the topic, the user intent, and what makes content valuable. AI just lets that person's judgment scale to thousands of pages.
The Technical Infrastructure Nobody Talks About
Generating 10,000 pages is easy. Generating 10,000 pages that don't tank your site performance, confuse Google, or create a maintenance nightmare? That's harder.
Crawl budget management. Google isn't going to crawl all 10,000 pages immediately. It might not crawl them all for months. You need to prioritize. Use internal linking to signal importance. Put your best pages in XML sitemaps. Use robots.txt strategically. Monitor your server logs to see what Google's actually crawling.
Staging and testing environments. Generate pages in batches. Test them. Check indexation rates. Monitor rankings. Then generate the next batch. I watched a company launch 50,000 pages at once, discover a template bug, and have to redirect everything. Don't be that company.
URL structure that scales. /city/austin/ is better than /austin-texas-united-states-page-12345/. Clean, logical URLs that humans can understand. Avoid deep nesting (more than 3-4 levels gets problematic). Consider how you'll handle variations and filters without creating duplicate content.
Canonical tag strategy. With programmatic pages, you'll inevitably create similar pages. Decide upfront which is the canonical version. Be consistent. Don't let Google choose for you.
Performance optimization. 10,000 pages means 10,000 opportunities for slow load times. Lazy load images. Minimize JavaScript. Use CDNs. Every millisecond matters when Google's deciding whether to keep crawling your site.
Monitoring and alerts. You need to know immediately if pages stop indexing, rankings drop, or traffic tanks. Set up Search Console monitoring. Track indexation rates. Monitor Core Web Vitals across page types. Problems at scale compound quickly.
Tripadvisor generates millions of pages, but they've spent years optimizing their technical infrastructure to handle it. Your WordPress site with a shared hosting plan probably isn't ready for 10,000 new pages next Tuesday.
The Quality Threshold Test
Before you generate anything, run this test: Take your template and data for 10 random pages. Generate them. Then honestly ask:
- Would I link to this page from my homepage?
- Would I share this page if a friend asked for information on this topic?
- Does this page offer something I couldn't get from the top 3 Google results?
- Would I be proud to have my name on this content?
- If Google showed this page to searchers, would it improve their experience?
If you're answering no to most of these, you're building a problem, not a solution. Scale amplifies both quality and garbage. Choose wisely.
The sites that succeed with programmatic SEO treat each page as a potential entry point for users who have a specific need. The sites that fail treat pages as lottery tickets—throw enough out there and maybe some will rank.
Google's gotten pretty good at telling the difference.
When to Scale and When to Wait
Here's what nobody wants to hear: you might not be ready for programmatic SEO yet.
If you don't have:
- A robust data infrastructure
- Clear search intent for each page variation
- Technical capacity to handle the load
- Systems to maintain and update pages
- Enough domain authority to rank competitive terms
Then generating 10,000 pages will just give you 10,000 unindexed pages that drain your resources.
Start smaller. Generate 100 pages. See what happens. Do they index? Do they rank? Do they get traffic? Do users engage with them? Learn from that before you scale to 10,000.
Some of the best programmatic SEO implementations I've seen started with 50 pages, perfected the model, then gradually scaled over months. The worst ones generated everything on day one and spent the next year cleaning up the mess.
What Actually Works in November 2025
The programmatic SEO strategies seeing success right now share common patterns:
Data-first approaches. Companies investing more in unique data than in content generation. Building proprietary datasets, aggregating information from multiple sources, creating original research and statistics.
Hybrid models. Using programmatic pages for long-tail, high-intent searches while manually creating content for competitive head terms. The programmatic pages feed users into the manually optimized conversion paths.
User-generated content integration. Reviews, ratings, comments, photos. This adds uniqueness and freshness without requiring constant manual updates. Yelp's model still works because user contributions make each page genuinely different.
Transparent value propositions. Pages that clearly explain what information they provide and why it's useful. No pretending to be comprehensive when you're not. No fake authority. Just honest utility.
Continuous optimization. Treating programmatic SEO as a product, not a project. Regular updates to templates, data refreshes, performance improvements, quality audits. The initial launch is just the beginning.
The companies doing this well aren't trying to game Google. They're using automation to serve user needs at scale. There's a difference.
The Honest Reality Check
Programmatic SEO is not a shortcut. It's not easy money. It's not a hack.
It's a way to scale content creation when you have:
- Legitimate user needs at scale
- Data to support unique pages
- Technical infrastructure to handle it
- Resources to maintain it
- Patience to let it work
If you're thinking "I'll just generate 10,000 pages this weekend and watch the traffic roll in"—that's not how this works. That's how you end up with a manual action and a recovery project.
But if you're thinking "I have valuable data, clear user intent, and a systematic approach to creating useful pages at scale"—then programmatic SEO might be exactly what you need.
The difference between those two mindsets is the difference between programmatic SEO and spam. Choose accordingly.
Because Google's watching. And in 2025, they're better at spotting the difference than ever.
Top comments (0)