DEV Community

Cover image for Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook Android photo access
The daily flare
The daily flare

Posted on Originally published at thedailyflare.com

Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook Android photo access

Originally published on The Daily Flare.

Italy fines Meta €805 million on Nov. 14 over Facebook Android photo access, after the country’s privacy authority said the app used gallery data without specific, informed consent.

The Garante, Italy’s data protection authority, said the Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and related metadata stored on Italian users’ smartphones. The feature at issue, introduced in 2023, suggests images from a phone’s gallery as ideas for posts while someone browses Facebook. The authority said about 20 million Android users in Italy could have been affected.

Facebook requested gallery access through a single authorisation for the app, the Garante said. Before the request, users saw a generic notice about enabling other features, which the authority said did not explain that permission would also allow the app to suggest material from the gallery. The suggestions option was set to active by default. The regulator said this could allow the app to read the photo archive on an ongoing basis without adequate user control.

The authority found that the consent process breached Article 122 of Italy’s privacy code, which implements the EU ePrivacy directive. In its explanation, the Garante said the rule protects a person’s smartphone as an extension of their private sphere and requires free, informed consent, whether or not data is transmitted or harm is demonstrated.

The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano consumer protection centre, ANSA reported. Meta had argued that the case should fall under the jurisdiction of Ireland’s data protection authority. The Garante rejected that objection, saying the ePrivacy rules involved do not provide for the EU’s “one-stop shop” mechanism.

The Garante cited the number of people affected, the length of time the practice had continued and Meta’s lack of cooperation when setting the penalty. It said the issue remained ongoing for people who had not updated the app and for users who had already consented to the system. ANSA also reported that the authority considered a previous measure against Meta from 2019 and viewed corrective changes as late. The fine was put at about 0.47 percent of Meta’s global turnover.

Meta has 60 days to keep the feature switched off by default and introduce a separate, clear consent request explaining that it accesses the phone’s gallery and how users can disable it. The order also covers people who had previously agreed to the feature. Once the deadline passes, the tool must be blocked for users without valid consent. ANSA reported that Meta must tell the authority within 30 days what steps it has started and provide an account of the measures taken within 90 days.

A Meta spokesperson told the BBC the company would appeal, saying: “We strongly disagree with the [regulator’s] assessment of the facts, its application of the law, and the disproportionate level of the fine.” The company described the feature as a straightforward tool to help people post photos and videos. It said: “People must give permission on their device before it can operate, and they can change this permission at any time via their settings.”

The case concerned the gallery-suggestion feature, not whether photos were used to train artificial intelligence. Meta has denied using the files for that purpose. ANSA reported that the Garante reserved the possibility of separate checks on a cloud-processing feature Meta launched in 2026.

Top comments (1)

Collapse
 
alexcodebytes profile image
Oleksandr •

What stands out to me isn't just the size of the fine, but the regulator's focus on consent design. A lot of privacy discussions revolve around what data is collected, while the bigger question is often whether users actually understood what they were agreeing to in the first place.

Features enabled by default and bundled permissions have been controversial for years, so it'll be interesting to see how the appeal addresses that issue.