Three quotes for the same fire detection upgrade can land on your desk and still describe three different jobs. One prices new detectors only, one includes panel work and testing, and one assumes the site will be empty for a week. If the scope of works is loose, the lowest price often just reflects the least work assumed.
For a commercial or industrial site in Western Australia, the fix is to decide what you are buying before you ask anyone to price it. This guide walks through the parts of a dry fire or fire detection scope that most often go missing, the trade-offs behind them, and the questions worth asking every contractor.
Start with the building and the approval path
The first thing a contractor needs to know is what kind of building this is and whether the work touches the approval process. The DFES Built Environment Branch advises building surveyors on whether plans for new or existing commercial and industrial buildings (Building Classifications 2 to 9) comply with the fire safety sections of the National Construction Code (NCC) and the FES Commissioner's Operational Requirements.
That matters for timing. To comply with Building Regulations 2012 18B(1), a building surveyor must provide plans and specifications for the building in sufficient detail to allow assessment of compliance with the FES Commissioner's Operational Requirements, and DFES says the submission must be made at least 15 business days before a Certificate of Design Compliance is signed for a Class 2 to Class 9 building. The Building Regulations 2012 set out the details, including when that step does not apply.
DFES also notes that the more plans and specifications deviate from the NCC and Operational Requirements, the more resources and time a review needs. Where a Performance Solution is proposed, it recommends lodging a Performance-Based Design Brief or Fire Engineering Brief, followed by a Fire Engineering Report. If your project has a fire engineer, put that in the brief, because it changes who designs what.
What to put in your brief:
- The building class, if your surveyor or designer has confirmed it.
- Whether the work is part of a building permit, a fitout or an upgrade to an existing system.
- Whether a fire engineer, building surveyor or head contractor is already involved, and who holds the drawings.
Name the system parts, not just the outcome
A request to simply upgrade the fire alarm describes an outcome, not a scope. A useful scope lists the parts of the system the work touches, so each contractor prices the same things.
The NCC's Specification 20 on smoke detection and alarm systems shows why. In Class 2 to 9 buildings, a smoke detection system must comply with AS 1670.1 and activate a building occupant warning system. So detection is never only the detectors. It includes the panel, the device network and the warning system that tells people to leave.
A practical checklist for the scope:
- Detection devices: new, replaced or relocated, and in which areas.
- Fire detection panel: new, modified or reprogrammed.
- Occupant warning or EWIS (emergency warning and intercommunication system) work.
- Interfaces with other systems the site already has.
- Emergency and exit lighting, if it is part of the same package.
- Testing, commissioning and the handover records you expect at the end.
The trade-off here is detail against speed. A one-line request gets fast quotes, but each contractor fills the gaps with their own assumptions. A listed scope takes longer to write and gives you prices you can actually compare.
Say whether the site stays open
Occupied sites change everything about how fire work is staged. If tenants, staff or the public stay in the building, the work usually has to be phased so protection is not lost across the whole site at once.
Ask each contractor how long any part of the system will be offline. DFES requests a Fire System Impairment Notice for fire systems undergoing repair or maintenance work that will extend for a period greater than 24 hours before the system is returned to its required operational performance. DFES says that responsibility for notification lies with the building owner, local council or private certifier, private alarm monitoring company where engaged, property manager or other relevant parties. A scope that names who lodges that notice, and who arranges any extra safety measures during the outage, removes a common source of argument later.
Questions to ask every contractor
Before you compare prices, ask each contractor the same questions:
- What exactly is included, and what have you assumed is excluded?
- Who holds the electrical contractor licence for the work, and what is the licence number?
- How will the work be staged if the site stays occupied, and how long will any system be offline?
- What testing is included, and what documents will we receive at handover?
- Which other trades or consultants do you need information from before you start?
If two quotes answer these questions differently, you have found the real difference between them, and it is rarely the bottom-line number.
Where Crossfire Electrical fits
Crossfire Electrical Services is a WA-owned fire safety and electrical contractor whose core capability is dry fire, fire detection and fire safety electrical delivery for commercial and industrial clients, under electrical contractor licence EC17675. Its scope covers fire detection panels, device networks and EWIS, phased occupied-site upgrades, and compliance testing with documented handover records, and it confirms site type, compliance needs, access and timing before pricing.
If you are preparing a dry fire or fire detection scope for a site, a fitout or an upgrade program, contact Crossfire Electrical with your building details and the checklist above, and ask for a proposal built on the same scope you are sending everyone else.
Top comments (0)