DEV Community

Discussion on: My solution is the best!

Collapse
 
thomasjunkos profile image
Thomas Junkツ

I would like to disagree. Not on the whole, because your point is about respect and not choice of solutions. In that respect I fully agree.

But you subtly mixed two points:
From a global point of view there might be no uber-solution which is best in all respects, but given a concrete situation and a fixed set of criteria, there might be a best in that respect, that one solution fits best into your requirements.

Why am I pointing that out? Because one could get the impression that when there is no best solution choice doesn't matter. Not that you are implying this, but you do not exclude this way of reading.

Being long enough in the industry, people realize not only that there is no best, but that there are a lot of crappy solutions mostly differing in the way they are broken. But that doesn't mean that there is never a best fit for your requirements.

Collapse
 
jhotterbeekx profile image
John Hotterbeekx

I like the way you look at this and the idea that choice doesn't matter is a different extreme that may even be a lot more dangerous. As with everything the key for these things is balance. I love your additional insight, thanks!