DEV Community

Cover image for Which Rules Actually Require a Pen Test? CIS 18, FTC 314.4(d)(2), SB 2610 and the HIPAA Proposal
Uprite Services
Uprite Services

Posted on

Which Rules Actually Require a Pen Test? CIS 18, FTC 314.4(d)(2), SB 2610 and the HIPAA Proposal

Whether a small company is required to run a penetration test depends on which framework or rule it falls under, and those texts disagree more than people expect. Texas businesses ask us about this a lot when a cyber insurance application shows up, so we read 4 of the relevant texts straight from the source documents. Here's how each one handles pen testing.
The problem
Cyber insurance applications ask about pen testing, but they don't make it a condition of coverage. Of the 7 carrier forms we read from Travelers, AXIS and At-Bay, none did. So the real requirement, when there is one, comes from a framework or a regulation. Four come up for a typical Texas business, namely Texas SB 2610, CIS Controls v8.1 Control 18, the FTC Safeguards Rule and the proposed HIPAA Security Rule update.
How each one handles testing
Text Names a pen test? Interval Applies to
Texas SB 2610, Business and Commerce Code ch. 542 No None Texas businesses under 250 employees that hold sensitive personal information
CIS Controls v8.1, Control 18 Yes, from IG2 up External test no less than annually (18.2) Anyone adopting CIS at IG2 or IG3
FTC Safeguards Rule, 16 CFR 314.4(d)(2) Yes, unless effective continuous monitoring Annual pen test, vulnerability assessments at least every 6 months Non-bank financial firms such as tax preparers and mortgage brokers
HIPAA Security Rule proposal, January 2025 Yes, proposed At least once every 12 months Covered entities and business associates, if HHS finalizes it
SB 2610 tiers resolve to CIS implementation groups
SB 2610 took effect September 1, 2025. It bars exemplary damages after a breach if the business had a qualifying cybersecurity program in place, and the program it asks for depends on headcount.
20 to 99 employees need "the requirements of the Center for Internet Security Controls Implementation Group 1."
100 to 249 employees need to conform to a full framework such as NIST or the CIS Controls.
The bill text never uses the word penetration. So for the smaller tier, the question becomes which CIS safeguards sit in IG1.
Control 18 starts at IG2
In CIS Controls version 8.1.2, Control 18 covers penetration testing. Safeguards 18.1 through 18.3 start at IG2, and 18.4 and 18.5 start at IG3. Safeguard 18.2 calls for an external test "no less than annually." Nothing in Control 18 is assigned to IG1.
That means a company with 20 to 99 employees can meet the SB 2610 IG1 tier without ever buying a pen test. Testing enters at IG2, which some companies with 100 to 249 employees may pick as their framework.
FTC 314.4(d)(2) is an either-or
The text says testing "shall include continuous monitoring or periodic penetration testing and vulnerability assessments." If a firm lacks "effective continuous monitoring," it has to run "annual penetration testing of your information systems" and vulnerability assessments "at least every six months." Written as logic, the rule looks like this.
if effective_continuous_monitoring:
requirement met by monitoring
else:
penetration_test every 12 months
vulnerability_assessment every 6 months
HIPAA is still a proposal
HHS published the proposed Security Rule update in the Federal Register on January 6, 2025. The proposed text reads "Penetration testing must be performed at least once every 12 months." When we checked in November 2026, the proposal was still the only document filed under its regulation number, RIN 0945-AA22. Nothing in it binds a clinic until HHS finalizes it.
Working out your own requirement
List which texts reach you. That means headcount for SB 2610, FTC coverage if you're a non-bank financial firm, HIPAA status if you handle patient records, and PCI DSS if you store or process card data.
If you're in SB 2610's 20 to 99 employee tier, check your program against IG1. Pen testing isn't part of it.
If the FTC rule applies, decide whether your monitoring is "effective continuous monitoring." If you can't defend that, schedule the annual test and the 6-month assessments.
Read the carrier form you're actually signing and answer its testing question with the work you've done.
Gotchas
Scans aren't pen tests on the forms. Travelers lists annual penetration testing (item 7m) and annual network security assessments (item 7n) as separate items, and AXIS asks for scan frequency in one section and pen testing in the next.
The FTC rule doesn't define effective monitoring. A tax office that pays for 24/7 security monitoring should still ask whoever reviews its program whether that service counts.
PCI DSS has its own testing schedule. A business that takes cards should confirm it with its payment processor or assessor.
Form editions vary. Both Travelers forms carry a January 2019 edition date, and the At-Bay form is written for technology companies.
A pen test is a poor first purchase when MFA isn't on email and remote access or nobody has tested a restore, because the tester will spend paid days on gaps a checklist already shows.
Takeaway
Of the 4 texts, only the FTC Safeguards Rule requires a pen test today, and only when effective continuous monitoring isn't in place. The full carrier form wording and 12 months of North Texas breach numbers are in our guide on pen test requirements for cyber insurance in Dallas.

Top comments (0)