When I started designing Krillion Unlimited, the hard problem was not the 20-second timer or the six category currents. It was this: a rare-answer game only works if "rare" means something, and on day one a prompt has no crowd to measure.
The official Krillion at krillion.io already has a daily dive and its own Unlimited mode. The game on my site is a separate, unofficial, fan-made version with its own 48 prompts and about 2,400 answers. It is free, runs in the browser, and has no sign-up. I mention that so the scoring notes below are not mistaken for official rules.
Starter tiers, then live numbers
Every accepted answer begins in one of three tiers I assigned myself: Surface at 20 points, Midwater at 55, and Trench at 90. Those numbers are a starting guess. They describe how obvious the answer felt when I wrote the list, not how a living player base has actually answered.
Once at least 15 players have answered that prompt on this site, the game stops using the guess. It scores with a simple formula the page states in plain language: 100 minus the share of players who gave the same answer, times 100, with a minimum of 5. If 30% of players said the same thing, the answer is worth 70. If almost nobody said it, the score approaches 100. A perfect 100 is 1,000 metres, because each point is 10 metres of depth.
I waited until 15 answers on purpose. With three or four plays, one popular name can look rarer than it is, or a trench pick can look common because two friends happened to type it. Fifteen is still a small sample. I would rather keep a hand-set Midwater score for a quiet prompt than publish a live rarity based on a handful of dives.
The minimum of 5 matters too. I did not want a fully exhausted common answer to be worth nothing, because a correct answer still has to count. It should just be a shallow dive.
Why a crowd answer costs a pearl
A dive starts with three pearls. The dive ends when the last one is gone, and the depth goes on the weekly board. You lose a pearl if the timer runs out, if you press Pass, or if you give the crowd's answer. The site treats an answer worth less than 25 points as a crowd pick. Surface starts at 20, so the first name most people would type is already under that line.
That is a design choice, not flavour text. In a game you can replay all day, a cheap Surface answer would otherwise become a safe way to keep a dive alive forever. I wanted the opposite: an obvious correct answer is a life spent. Midwater is the honest compromise when I am not sure a trench name is on the list.
Answering faster does not earn extra points, so there is no reason to snap in a Surface name at second two. The tide line under the score bar turns coral in the last few seconds. That is the only hurry the game asks for. If the first word is not on the list, you can try another while the clock runs. Plurals, capital letters, accents and one small typo in a longer word are forgiven; a different word is not.
A small prompt pool, and a board that resets
The pool is 48 prompts across six currents: Geography, Sports, Food & Drink, Animals & Nature, Pop Culture and Words, or All currents for a mix. After a long session you will see prompts again. The game shows ones you have not seen recently first, and it keeps a best depth for each current in the browser.
I kept the pool small on purpose so that live rarity can actually form. A generator that invents a new prompt every time would never reach 15 answers. A short list with long tails — African countries, pasta shapes, words with a silent K — is what lets a Trench pick become a real-data score instead of a permanent guess.
When a dive ends, the depth is sent to the weekly board, which resets every Monday. You can set a board name of up to 20 characters. Nothing else about you is stored: no email, no account, no real name. A small cookie keeps you as the same anonymous player so your best depth and board name are remembered. Clear the cookies or switch devices, and you start fresh.
I reset the board weekly so a late arrival is not staring at an all-time list they cannot catch. This weekly board only ranks dives on my site.
What I show after you answer
After you dive, the game shows your tier, your points and, once enough people have answered, the share of players who said the same thing. It also shows a few trench answers from the list. That reveal is part of the scoring design. A rare-answer game that never teaches the tail trains people to keep typing the same Midwater names.
If a valid answer was rejected, or a wrong one was accepted, the fix is not hidden in a settings menu. You can write to me from the contact page with the prompt and the answer. If it holds up, I add it to that prompt's list, and it counts for everyone from then on.
Krillion Unlimited is unofficial and not connected to Krillion or krillion.io. The prompts, the answer lists and this scoring model are my own. If you want to see how a current dive feels in practice, the game is free on the home page.
Top comments (0)