If you're shopping for a residential proxy provider in 2026, you've already narrowed it down to three names: Bright Data, Oxylabs, and Smartproxy. They dominate every "best proxies" list, they sponsor every scraping conference, and they all claim to be the best.
But they're not interchangeable. I've run production scraping jobs on all three — millions of requests across e-commerce, search engines, real estate, and social media targets. The differences are real, and picking the wrong one can cost you thousands in wasted bandwidth.
Here's the honest breakdown so you can stop reading marketing pages and start scraping.
Pricing Deep Dive
Proxy pricing is confusing by design. Every provider structures plans differently. Here's what you'll actually pay at different scales.
Small Scale (< 50 GB/month)
| Provider | Plan | Cost | Effective $/GB |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bright Data | Pay-as-you-go | Variable | $5.04/GB |
| Oxylabs | Micro plan | $300/mo for 29 GB | $10.34/GB |
| Smartproxy | Pay-as-you-go | Variable | $4.50/GB |
Winner at small scale: Smartproxy. No minimum commitment, lowest per-GB rate. Bright Data is close behind. Oxylabs' $300 minimum makes it expensive unless you'll use the full allocation.
Medium Scale (50–500 GB/month)
| Provider | Plan | Cost | Effective $/GB |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bright Data | Growth | $500/mo for ~110 GB | $4.55/GB |
| Oxylabs | Professional | $600/mo for 86 GB | $6.98/GB |
| Smartproxy | Business | $400/mo for ~100 GB | $4.00/GB |
Winner at medium scale: Smartproxy, but Bright Data's Web Unlocker (separate pricing at $3.40 per 1K requests) can reduce total bandwidth by avoiding retries. Factor that into your math.
Enterprise Scale (500+ GB/month)
At this level, everyone offers custom pricing. Expect:
- Bright Data: $3.00–3.50/GB
- Oxylabs: $4.00–5.00/GB
- Smartproxy: $3.00–3.50/GB
Winner at enterprise scale: Tie between Bright Data and Smartproxy on price. Bright Data wins on features and support.
The Decision Framework
Choose Bright Data if...
- You're scraping heavily protected sites (Cloudflare, Akamai, PerimeterX)
- You want a single vendor for proxies, SERP data, and browser automation
- Compliance and data governance matter for your business
- Budget is secondary to reliability
Choose Oxylabs if...
- Search engine scraping is your primary workload
- You operate at massive scale (1B+ requests/month)
- You need the largest IP pool for geographic diversity
- You want the strongest datacenter proxy offering alongside residential
Choose Smartproxy if...
- You're scraping moderate-difficulty targets (most e-commerce, job boards, real estate)
- Budget is a primary concern
- You want the simplest onboarding experience
- You're a solo developer or small team
Choose none of them if...
- You don't want to manage proxy infrastructure at all. In that case, a managed scraping API handles everything — proxies, rotation, retries, CAPTCHAs, browser rendering — with a single API call.
ScraperAPI is the best option here. You send a URL, you get HTML. No proxy configuration, no IP management, no CAPTCHA solving headaches. Plans start at $49/month for 100,000 API calls, and their success rates compete with the enterprise proxy providers.
If you're a developer who wants to write scraping logic — not proxy management logic — ScraperAPI is the answer. It's what I recommend to anyone who asks "which proxy should I use?" and doesn't have a specific reason to manage their own proxy infrastructure.
Top comments (0)