Disclosure: this article was drafted with AI assistance by the AIGB team and reviewed before publishing. Competitor details reflect publicly listed pricing/features at the time of writing and may change.
I run a few Telegram communities and got tired of juggling three bots: one for moderation, one for games, one for crypto giveaways. So I went through the major Telegram group management bots one by one, with real numbers. Here's the honest breakdown — including what each one does well.
The contenders
Combot, GroupHelp, Rose, Shieldy, moonpacket — and the new kid, AIGB (AI GroupButler), which is what I ended up standardizing on. Full comparison pages with migration guides live at gensi.space/alternatives, but here's the short version.
The comparison, in numbers
| Free tier | Engagement games | Red packets | AI admin | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Combot | Groups up to 200 members | XP levels, reputation | ❌ | ❌ (paid plans from €9.99/mo, community plan up to €767/yr) |
| GroupHelp | Broad moderation set | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ (premium add-ons in Stars) |
| Rose | Core moderation | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Shieldy | Captcha anti-spam only | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
| moonpacket | Red packet sending | ❌ | ✅ USDT/SOL/ETH/TON (standalone app) | ❌ |
| AIGB | $0 forever — full toolkit + 15+ games, no member cap | ✅ chains, polls, lotteries, check-in streaks, daily king, points mall, achievements, 72h onboarding, trivia | ✅ USDT/USDC built in (lucky-draw / password / dedicated) | ✅ $2/mo per 1,000 members (rounded down, $19.9 cap at 10k+) |
Three things worth calling out
1. The free-tier trap. Several "free" bots cap the free tier by member count — Combot's stops at 200 members, and after that you're paying monthly per group. AIGB's free tier genuinely doesn't cap members, messages, or groups. The paid layer is optional and per-1,000-members, not per-group.
2. "AI admin" means a workflow, not a chatbot. The interesting part of AIGB's paid tier isn't answering questions — it's that the AI writes a weekly report, turns it into an ops plan, and auto-executes scheduled tasks after you approve. It also holds group memory and a product knowledge base, and every member can get a 1-on-1 assistant with memory. That's $2/month per 1,000 total members, rounded down — a 10,000-member group pays the $19.9 cap, not $20+.
3. Red packets inside the admin suite. Crypto communities have been gluing standalone red packet apps onto moderation bots. AIGB embeds USDT/USDC red packets (lucky-draw, password, dedicated) next to lotteries and check-in streaks — so a streak winner gets paid without leaving the group. If you need SOL/ETH/TON packets, moonpacket is still a fine standalone tool; AIGB covers USDT/USDC.
What the classics still do well
Being fair: Rose's moderation core is rock-solid and years-proven. Shieldy's captcha is simple and open-source. GroupHelp's free moderation covers day-one needs. Combot's XP/reputation tracking is genuinely mature. If you only need that one thing, they're fine. The trade-off is running (and paying for) multiple bots as your group grows.
Migration is boringly simple
- Add the bot: t.me/groupbutleraibot?startgroup=true
- Set captcha, filters, anti-raid thresholds, trigger chains — and federated ban if you run multiple groups (ban once, applies everywhere)
- Turn on the free games the same day; start 3-day trials on the AI admin or crypto pro pack ($9.9/mo flat: 66-signal token safety checks, price alerts, whale CRM) only if you want them
Every paid module has a 3-day free trial, payment in Telegram Stars or USDT, and all paid tiers are currently at founder's launch pricing.
Links: gensi.space · full bot-by-bot comparisons · pricing
Tags: telegram, community, ai, productivity — because that's where my head's been at 2am.
Top comments (0)