One site tells you the numbers. One tells you which model wins a blind vote. The third — which I built — tells you whether people think it's worth the money.
If you've ever picked an AI model because the benchmarks said so, and then regretted it a week later, you know those three things are not the same. Here's the difference.
1. Artificial Analysis — the numbers
Artificial Analysis is the closest thing the AI world has to a spec sheet.
It measures intelligence, speed, and price across hundreds of models, updates constantly, and doesn't have an opinion. That's the point, and it's also the limit.
What it's good for: the honest answer to "which model is objectively the strongest right now."
What it's not: a recommendation. A model can top the intelligence index and still be a miserable thing to use for your actual job. Artificial Analysis won't tell you that, because it's not trying to.
Website: https://artificialanalysis.ai
2. LMArena — the blind vote
LMArena shows you two anonymous answers and asks which is better. Millions of votes later, you get an Elo ranking that reflects what humans actually prefer.
What it's good for: the answer to "which one feels better to talk to."
What it's not: the answer to "which one should I pay for." A blind vote can't tell you if the model that wins is also the one that burns your monthly quota in an afternoon. Preference is not the same as value.
Website: https://lmarena.ai
3. highworth.ai — the "worth it" score (I built this one)
Highworth flips the question from "which is better" to "was it worth the money."
Every model gets a score from real people who've used it — pulled from Hacker News, Reddit, V2EX, and Bilibili, with every quote linked back to its source. The result is a percentage: what share of people thought it was worth paying for.
What it's good for: the honest answer to "should I spend on this."
What it's not: a benchmark. The sample is smaller than the big arenas, and the audience skews technical. A score from three reviews is not the same as one from fifty, and we say that on the page.
Website: https://highworth.ai
So which one do you use?
The boring but true answer: all three, in order.
- Start with Artificial Analysis to see what's objectively strong.
- Check LMArena to see what people actually like using.
- Then check highworth to see if people thought it was worth paying for.
One tells you what's best. One tells you what's preferred. One tells you what's worth it. You usually need all three before you open your wallet.
Top comments (0)