Four rounds, a take home exercise, a long afternoon of conversations that you thought went well. Then an email. We have decided to move forward with other candidates. We wish you every success.
You reread it looking for something, and there is nothing to find, because it was written to contain nothing. Companies are careful here for reasons that have little to do with you. Legal caution, a recruiter who was not in the rooms, a policy that says one template for everyone.
So you are left to guess, and guessing after a rejection is reliably unkind. Most people settle on the most flattering explanation or the most damning one, and both are usually wrong. Often the real reason was ordinary. An internal candidate. A budget change. Somebody who had done nearly this exact job before.
You can sometimes get better than that, and it is worth one careful attempt.
Reply once, briefly, to whoever you had the best rapport with, which is often the hiring manager rather than the recruiter. Thank them, say you are not disputing the decision, and ask one narrow question. Was there one area where the other candidate was clearly stronger? Is there one thing you would suggest I work on before my next interview? Narrow questions get answered because they are safe to answer. A broad one gets another template.
Many will not reply. Some will send something short and genuinely useful, and occasionally you will get a paragraph that changes how you prepare for years.
Then give yourself your own feedback, the same evening, while it is fresh. Which question did you answer worse than you know the material? Where did you ramble? What did you not ask them that you now wish you had? Write it down. You were in every one of those rooms, which makes your notes the most complete record anybody has.
And keep those notes across interviews. One rejection tells you very little. Three with the same weak spot is a pattern, and a pattern is something you can fix before the next one.
The email was not a verdict on you. It was a closed door with no handle on your side. Knock once, politely, then look at the room you were in.
– Asael Shinder
Top comments (0)