DEV Community

Asael Shinder
Asael Shinder

Posted on

You Have Been Asked to Help Interview Your Next Manager

Your manager has left, and the company is hiring a replacement from outside. Then the head of engineering asks whether you would join one of the interviews. It is a strange invitation. You are being asked to judge someone who, if they get the job, will be judging you.

Say yes. It is one of the few times you get a direct say in something that will shape the next few years of your working life. It also puts you in front of senior people in a role where you are trusted, and they will notice how you handle it.

Start by asking what your part is. Are you one voice among several, or is your view a veto? Usually it is the first, and it helps to know that before you walk in. Ask too what the other interviewers are covering, so your hour adds something new.

Your best contribution is the view from the team. The hiring panel can test strategy and budgets. You can test what it would be like to work for this person on an ordinary Tuesday. Ask how they found out that someone in a previous team was struggling, and what they did. Ask about a time they disagreed with their own manager and what happened next. Ask how they decide what to protect their team from and what to pass on. Listen for real examples with names of situations, not general statements about valuing people.

Talk to your teammates before the interview. What do they most need from a new manager? Bring those questions in, so you are speaking for the team and not only for yourself.

Be careful with your own feelings. You may have liked your old manager and resent anyone new, or you may hope for the opposite of them. Neither is a fair basis for judging the candidate in front of you.

Write your view down straight afterwards, with what you heard and what concerned you. Keep it factual and kind.

And whoever is hired, keep what you saw in the interview to yourself. Start the new relationship fresh. They will know you took part, and the most useful thing you can show them is that it did not make you their critic in advance.

– Asael Shinder

Top comments (0)