DEV Community

Cover image for EKS vs ECS: A Comprehensive Comparison
Tandap Noel Bansikah
Tandap Noel Bansikah

Posted on

EKS vs ECS: A Comprehensive Comparison

#aws #kubernetes #cloudnative #devops

What Problem Are We Solving?

Imagine you're running a restaurant. You have multiple chefs (containers) cooking different dishes (applications). Now, who decides:

  • Which chef works on which dish?
  • What happens if a chef gets sick mid-service?
  • How many chefs do you need during the lunch rush vs. a quiet Tuesday afternoon?

In the software world, containers are like those chefs—small, independent workers running your applications. And just like a restaurant needs a manager to coordinate everything, containers need a container orchestrator.

What is Container Orchestration?

Container orchestration is simply automated container management. Think of it as an intelligent manager that:

Task What It Means
Deployment Deciding where each container should run
Scaling Adding more containers when traffic spikes, removing them when it's quiet
Self-healing Automatically restarting containers that crash
Load balancing Spreading incoming traffic evenly across containers

Without orchestration, you'd have to manually start, stop, monitor, and manage potentially hundreds of containers. That's not practical—or fun.

Meet the Two AWS Solutions

AWS offers two main container orchestration services:

  1. ECS (Elastic Container Service) — AWS's own solution
  2. EKS (Elastic Kubernetes Service) — Managed Kubernetes on AWS

Let's break down each one.

Amazon ECS: The Simple Choice

What is ECS?

ECS is AWS's homegrown container orchestration service. It's designed to be straightforward and works seamlessly with other AWS services.

Think of ECS as hiring a property management company that only works with buildings in one city (AWS). They know that city inside and out, making everything smooth—but you can't use them if you ever move to another city.

How Does ECS Work?

ECS has two main parts:

  1. Control Plane — The "brain" that decides what runs where (AWS manages this for you—for free!)
  2. Compute — The actual servers that run your containers

Where Do Your Containers Actually Run?

You have two options:

Option 1: EC2 Launch Type

You provide your own virtual servers (EC2 instances), and ECS places containers on them.

Pros:

  • More control over the underlying servers
  • Can be cheaper for steady, predictable workloads

Cons:

  • You manage the servers (updates, security patches, capacity)

Option 2: Fargate Launch Type

AWS handles everything. You just say "run this container" and AWS figures out the rest.

Pros:

  • Zero server management
  • Pay only for what you use, down to the second
  • Perfect for variable workloads

Cons:

  • Can be more expensive for always-on workloads
  • Less control over the underlying infrastructure

Amazon EKS: The Kubernetes Option

What is EKS?

EKS is Kubernetes managed by AWS. Kubernetes (often called "K8s") is the industry-standard container orchestrator, originally created by Google.

Think of EKS as hiring an internationally certified property management company. They follow global standards, so if you ever move to another city (another cloud provider), your processes stay the same.

Why Does Kubernetes Exist?

Running Kubernetes yourself is hard. You'd need to:

  • Set up and secure master nodes (the control plane)
  • Install and configure multiple complex components
  • Handle upgrades, backups, and high availability
  • Keep everything secure and patched

EKS takes care of all the hard parts. AWS manages the control plane, and you just focus on running your applications.

Where Do Your Containers Run on EKS?

Just like ECS, you need compute resources. EKS gives you three options:

Option 1: Self-Managed Nodes

You create and manage your own EC2 instances, installing all the necessary Kubernetes components yourself.

Best for: Teams needing maximum customization or specific compliance requirements.

Option 2: Managed Node Groups (Recommended)

AWS creates and manages EC2 instances for you. Updates and patches happen automatically.

Best for: Most production workloads. You get convenience without giving up too much control.

Option 3: Fargate

Completely serverless. AWS handles everything—you don't even think about servers.

Best for: Variable workloads or teams that want zero infrastructure management.

ECS vs EKS: The Honest Comparison

Let's compare these services across what actually matters:

Learning Curve

ECS EKS
Easier — Simple concepts, AWS-native terminology Harder — Must learn Kubernetes concepts plus AWS specifics
Can be productive in days May take weeks to become comfortable

Bottom line: If you're new to containers, ECS will get you running faster.

Cost

ECS EKS
Control plane is free Control plane is paid (per cluster per hour)
Pay only for compute (EC2 or Fargate) Pay for control plane + compute

Note: For current EKS pricing, refer to the official AWS EKS Pricing page. Pricing varies based on Kubernetes version support tier (standard vs. extended).

Bottom line: ECS is cheaper, especially for smaller deployments.

Vendor Lock-in

ECS EKS
AWS-only — your knowledge and configurations don't transfer Kubernetes is universal — skills transfer to any cloud
If AWS changes ECS, you adapt Kubernetes is open-source with a stable API

Bottom line: EKS gives you more flexibility and portability.

Ecosystem and Tooling

ECS EKS
Limited to AWS tools Massive ecosystem: Helm, ArgoCD, Istio, Prometheus, and hundreds more
Smaller community Huge global community with endless resources

Bottom line: EKS has a richer ecosystem and more community support.

Operational Complexity

ECS EKS
Simpler to operate day-to-day More moving parts to understand and manage
Less configuration needed More powerful, but more configuration required

Bottom line: ECS is easier to operate; EKS offers more power at the cost of complexity.

Making Your Decision: A Simple Framework

Ask yourself these questions:

Choose ECS if:

  • You're new to containers and want to start quickly
  • Your team is small and doesn't have Kubernetes experience
  • You're fully committed to AWS with no plans to use other clouds
  • You want the simplest possible setup
  • Cost optimization is a top priority

Choose EKS if:

  • Your team already knows Kubernetes
  • You might use multiple clouds in the future (AWS, Azure, GCP)
  • You need advanced features like service mesh, custom controllers, or complex networking
  • You want to use popular K8s tools (Helm, ArgoCD, etc.)
  • You're running large-scale, complex microservices

Real-World Scenarios

Scenario 1: Startup Building Their First App

Situation: A 5-person startup launching their first web application.

Recommendation: ECS with Fargate

Why? They need to move fast, have limited DevOps experience, and shouldn't spend time managing infrastructure. ECS is simpler, and Fargate means zero server management.

Scenario 2: Enterprise Migrating from On-Premises

Situation: A large company moving their existing Kubernetes workloads from on-premises data centers to AWS.

Recommendation: EKS with Managed Node Groups

Why? They already have Kubernetes expertise and existing configurations. EKS lets them reuse their knowledge and tooling with minimal changes.

Scenario 3: Company with Multi-Cloud Strategy

Situation: A company that uses AWS primarily but also deploys to Azure for specific clients.

Recommendation: EKS

Why? Kubernetes skills and configurations work across clouds. They can use similar practices on AWS (EKS) and Azure (AKS).

Quick Reference Cheat Sheet

Question ECS EKS
How hard is it to learn? Easy Moderate to Hard
What does the control plane cost? Free Paid (per cluster per hour)
Can I use it on other clouds? No Yes (Kubernetes is universal)
How big is the community? Small Massive
Best for beginners? Yes Not ideal
Best for Kubernetes users? No Yes
Serverless option? Fargate Fargate

Final Thoughts

There's no universally "better" choice between ECS and EKS—only what's better for your situation.

ECS is like an automatic car: easy to learn, gets you where you need to go, and requires less attention. Perfect for most drivers.

EKS is like a manual car: more control, more powerful in the right hands, but requires more skill to operate well. Preferred by enthusiasts and professionals.

Start with what matches your team's skills and your project's needs. You can always evolve your choice as your requirements grow.

References

Top comments (0)