DEV Community

Discussion on: Javascript needs competition on the front end. Thoughts?

 
cjbrooks12 profile image
Casey Brooks

I'm expecting this to catch on more than Kotlin/JS because of Kotlin's relationship with Android. More likely for people to want to share Kotlin code between Android/iOS than backend/frontend. In my (quite limited) experience, Java-based backends seem to be used more for microservices and APIs, as opposed to full stacks like with Rails or PHP backends, leaving less incentive to introduce Kotlin into a JS codebase.

That being said, I think the popularity of Typescript and Flow show that web developers do want static typing, I'm just not sure how likely it will be for Kotlin to become a popular option.

Thread Thread
 
ben profile image
Ben Halpern

I feel like any attempt to move Kotlin away from the JVM is a step towards compiling to all sorts of places because the big hiccup when moving off is that you can no longer dip into the Java ecosystem to fill the gaps. It forces certain problems to be solved which could than make the next thing easier.

Thread Thread
 
vitalcog profile image
Chad Windham • Edited

"That being said, I think the popularity of Typescript and Flow show that web developers do want static typing, I'm just not sure how likely it will be for Kotlin to become a popular option."

Well... Some do. And a lot of web developers really like JS and don't feel like it being a static language adds any real value. I think both sides of the argument make sense. I definitely understand peoples reasons for loving typescript. I work on a huge app built with angular 2+. And I honestly hate typescript. I have yet to see "static typing" solve any problems that arise from bad coding practices that slip through the cracks when you have 200+ devs working on the same app. (which is the promise of typescript). In my real world working experience, typescript is just an extra-bloated superset of javascript that doesn't actually fix any problems. I think the real strength of typescript is it makes people who are very familiar with static languages happier with JS...