Staying invested beats selling during market volatility.That is the short answer. In 32 years advising business owners and investors, the most expensive decision I have watched people make is not a bad investment. It is leaving early. If you are anxious about the market right now and wondering whether to step aside until things calm down, this post is for you.
Key Takeaways
- Leaving early almost always costs more than staying.The investors who exit in fear tend to miss the recovery.
- A written financial plan is what keeps you in your seat.Not a forecast. Not a prediction. A plan you agreed to before the panic started.
- Cash reserves matter.If you have near-term needs covered, you are not a forced seller at the worst moment.
- A scary headline is not a reason to change your plan.A genuine change in your goals or risk capacity is.
- The advisor's job is not to call the final score.It is to keep you from walking out in the seventh inning.
A House-Divided Weekend in Our Family
My younger son went to Oregon. I am a Texas guy through and through. So this weekend, our family is a house divided. Texas baseball versus the Ducks. We have been texting back and forth all week, the good-natured kind of trash talk that only works when you genuinely love the other person.
I love live sports. Always have. There is something about being in the stands, surrounded by people who care about the same thing you do, that you simply cannot replicate on a screen. The energy is real. The uncertainty is real. You do not know how it ends.
And that is exactly the point.
You Never Leave Until the Clock Says Zeros
Our family has a rule at live events.You never leave until the clock hits zero.Not when your team is down by two touchdowns. Not when the line at the parking garage is going to be brutal. Not when it is hot and the seventh inning feels like it will never end.
You stay. Because the people who leave early to beat traffic are the ones who miss the comeback.
I have seen it happen dozens of times in the stands. I have seen it happen hundreds of times in portfolios. The investor who sold in March 2020 because the headlines were terrifying. The business owner who moved everything to cash in late 2022 because the Fed was raising rates and it felt like the world was ending. The ones who left early missed the recovery.Every single time, the cost of leaving was real.
According toFINRA's investor education resources, emotional and short-term trading decisions are among the most common and costly mistakes individual investors make. The pattern is consistent: fear drives the exit, and the re-entry almost always comes too late.
Why Investors Walk Out Early
Fear Sells at the Bottom
When markets fall, fear feels like logic. The news is bad. The portfolio is down. Every instinct says do something.But selling into a downturn locks in the loss.It turns a temporary decline into a permanent one. The market does not know you sold. It recovers on its own schedule, not yours.
"I'll Get Back In When It's Calmer" Rarely Works
This is the trap. The investor who sells during volatility plans to re-enter once things settle down. But by the time things feel calm, prices have already recovered. You sold low. You buy back high. The gap between what investors earn and what the market actually returns is well-documented.Morningstar's annual Mind the Gap studyconsistently finds that investors underperform the very funds they own, because they buy and sell at the wrong times. The cost oftrying to time a market moveis not theoretical. It shows up in real account balances.
A Scary Headline Is Not a Plan Change
Markets have always had scary headlines. New Fed Chair. Geopolitical tension. Recession fears. Rate uncertainty. These are not new.What is new is the 24-hour news cycle that makes each one feel like the worst one yet.A headline is information. It is not a directive. Your plan was built to survive uncertainty. That is the whole point of having one.
What Actually Keeps You in Your Seat
A Written Plan You Decided on Before the Panic
The single most important tool I give clients is a written financial plan. Not a market forecast. Not a prediction about where rates are going. A document that says: here is what you own, here is why you own it, here is what you need it to do, and here is what we agreed to do when things get uncomfortable.That document is the reason you do not make a decision in the middle of a bad week.TheSEC's Office of Investor Education and Advocacyhas published guidance on the risks of market timing, noting that even professional investors rarely succeed at it consistently. A long-term plan is the evidence-based alternative.
Cash Set Aside for Near-Term Needs
One of the reasons people become forced sellers is that they need money. A medical expense. A business shortfall. A life event.If your near-term cash needs are covered outside your investment portfolio, you are not forced to sell at the worst moment.This is not complicated. It is just planning. Knowing how much cash to hold is part ofbuilding a portfolio you can hold through a cycle.
Knowing Your Time Horizon Is Longer Than the Current Quarter
Most investors have a time horizon measured in decades, not quarters. Your retirement is not next month. Your estate is not being settled this year.The current quarter is one data point in a very long game.When you remember that, the score in the seventh inning matters a lot less. You can stay in your seat because you know the game is not over.
The Advisor's Job Is Not to Call the Final Score
I am not going to tell you where the market is going. Nobody knows. What I can tell you is what I have watched over 32 years: the investors who had a plan and stayed with it, through 2008, through 2020, through every scary headline in between, came out better than the ones who tried to time their way to safety. That is not a guarantee.Past performance does not guarantee future results.Markets can decline and stay down. That is a real risk and it deserves honest acknowledgment.
But here is what I know about the behavioral mistakes investors make in volatile markets: most of them happen in the absence of a plan. When you have a written plan, a clear time horizon, and cash reserves for near-term needs, you have something to hold onto when the score looks ugly. You have a reason to stay in your seat.
My job is not to predict the final score. My job is to be the reason you do not walk out in the seventh inning. That is whatthe planning moves that give you optionsare really about.
Texas football season is coming. Our family will be back in the stands together, house divided or not. We will stay until the clock hits zero. That is the rule. It is a good rule for portfolios too.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does trying to time the market actually work for long-term investors?Historically, market timing has not worked reliably for long-term investors. According to theSEC's Office of Investor Education and Advocacy, even professional investors rarely succeed at timing the market consistently. Missing just a handful of the market's best days can significantly reduce long-term returns. A written plan built around your actual time horizon tends to outperform reactive decision-making over long periods, though past performance does not guarantee future results.What is the real cost of selling during a downturn?The cost of selling during a downturn is twofold. First, you lock in a loss that might have been temporary. Second, you face the challenge of deciding when to re-enter, and most investors re-enter too late, after prices have already recovered.Morningstar's Mind the Gap studydocuments this pattern consistently: investors tend to underperform the funds they own because they buy and sell at the wrong times. The gap is real and it compounds over time. Results vary based on individual circumstances.How does a financial plan stop me from panic selling?A written financial plan works because it was created before the panic started. It documents what you own, why you own it, what you need it to do, and what you agreed to do when markets get uncomfortable. When fear is high and headlines are bad, the plan gives you a framework that is not based on emotion. It is the difference between making a decision in the middle of a bad week and honoring a decision you made with a clear head.How much cash should I hold so I am not forced to sell at the wrong time?The right amount of cash depends on your personal situation, including your near-term spending needs, income sources, and overall financial plan. The general principle is that money you will need in the next one to three years should not be in long-term investments. If your near-term needs are covered by cash or cash equivalents, you are not a forced seller when markets decline. A qualified financial advisor can help you determine the right allocation for your specific circumstances.Is it ever right to change my investment plan during volatility?Yes. There is an important difference between a disciplined plan adjustment and a panic exit. If your goals have genuinely changed, your risk capacity has shifted, or your liquidity needs have increased, updating your plan is the right move. What is costly is changing your plan simply because markets are down and headlines are scary. A good financial plan should be reviewed regularly and updated when your life changes, not when the market does.
Work with Pinnacle Wealth Advisory
If any of this resonates with where you are right now, it might be worth a conversation. At Pinnacle Wealth Advisory, we work with business owners, executives, and pre-retirees who want a written plan they can hold onto when markets get uncomfortable. If this would be useful for your situation, here is where to start:pnwadvisory.com.
This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult with qualified professionals for guidance tailored to your specific situation. Results vary based on individual circumstances. Specific figures are illustrative, not guarantees of outcomes. Doug Greenberg is an investment adviser representative of SB Advisory LLC, a registered investment adviser. Doug may provide services and conduct business as Pinnacle Wealth Advisory with advisory services offered through SB Advisory, LLC.
Top comments (0)