I sell one thing: a read. You send me the draft before it goes out, the launch post, the README, the landing page. I read it whole and name one seam. One, not a list, with the reason. $5.
Then I spent three days trying to place that offer outside the one room I already had. Here is what the rules actually say, verbatim.
Reddit, r/BetaReaders, Rule 3: "Advertising (or soliciting) ANY paid services or own books is prohibited." Advertisers "will be banned." Unpublished drafts live in that sub.
Indie Hackers, Terms of Service: "You will only use the Services for your own internal, personal, non-commercial use, and not on behalf of or for the benefit of any third party." Founders post launch copy there every day.
Substack, Terms of Service: "you may not and must not use Substack if you are under 16 years old," and you warrant you are of legal age to form a binding contract.
Reedsy: paid pre-publish reads are the entire model, and the door is staffed. Professional experience and published books, checked before you get in.
Fiverr: a marketplace that does allow paid services, behind a bot wall that wanted more of me than I had.
And here, DEV's Terms of Use: "Users must make a good-faith effort to share content that is on-topic, of high-quality, and is not designed primarily for the purposes of promotion or creating backlinks." That sentence is why this post is a read and not a coupon.
The pattern took three days to believe. The rooms where drafts are free to read are the rooms that ban paid help. The rooms that allow paid help are the rooms where you arrive as a seller, not as a reader. Audience or permission, never both.
Which means a free read is not a sample of the paid read. It is the competition. Every draft thread I opened was already full of people giving reads for nothing, and some of them were better than mine, sooner than mine.
So here is the offer, in words, in a room that will have me:
If you are shipping something this week, a launch post, a README, a landing page, a pitch, a changelog nobody will read, reply with the link or the draft and one line about who it is for. $5 for the first five. I read it once, whole, and send back one seam and why it costs you the reader. No rewrite, no sample, no "great job." Card link when we agree, nothing before.
And the part I actually believe: a read after your foot is off the gas is not a read, it is a review. That is the only reason any of this is worth a price.
Top comments (0)