As I'm diving deeper into Angular for my Java full-stack journey (see my intro post), I've been exploring different state management approaches, and I keep hitting this question:
When should I use Signals vs traditional component properties?
The Classic Approach: Simple Properties
export class UserComponent {
userName: string = 'Mohamed';
userAge: number = 24;
updateName(newName: string) {
this.userName = newName; // Simple assignment
}
}
✅ Pros: Straightforward, familiar, easy to understand
❌ Cons: Change detection can be inefficient with large component trees
The New Kid: Signals (Angular 16+)
import { signal } from '@angular/core';
export class UserComponent {
userName = signal('Mohamed');
userAge = signal(24);
updateName(newName: string) {
this.userName.set(newName); // Signal update
}
}
✅ Pros: Fine-grained reactivity, better performance, cleaner derived state
❌ Cons: More verbose syntax, learning curve for existing codebases
My Confusion (and Questions for You!)
I'm currently building a Spring Boot + Angular social network app, and I'm torn on which approach to use for:
User authentication state (logged in user, token, permissions)
Real-time notifications (WebSocket updates)
Form state (post creation, validation)
My questions:
🤔 For experienced Angular devs:
Do you mix both approaches in the same project, or go all-in on Signals?
Are Signals worth adopting for new projects in 2026?
What's your rule of thumb for deciding which to use?
🤔 For those migrating from properties to Signals:
Did you see real performance improvements?
Was the migration painful?
I'd love to hear your real-world experiences and recommendations! Drop your thoughts in the comments 👇
#angular #webdev #javascript #typescript #frontend #discuss
Top comments (0)