In my analysis, around 60% of new product launches fail because brands rely on 'hope marketing' instead of structured assets. If you're scrambling to create content the week of launch, you've already lost the attention war. The brands that win have their entire creative arsenal ready before day one.
TL;DR: Agency Vetting for E-commerce Marketers
The Core Concept
In 2025, the role of a Facebook ad agency has shifted from manual media buying to creative strategy and technical data integration. Brands that hire agencies solely for "button pushing" often see diminishing returns due to automation tools like Advantage+ Shopping Campaigns (ASC).
The Strategy
Successful vetting now requires evaluating an agency's ability to produce high-volume creative assets and implement server-side tracking (CAPI) to combat signal loss. The most effective partners combine human strategy with AI-driven production velocity.
Key Metrics
- Creative Refresh Rate: Target 5-10 new concepts per week to combat fatigue.
- Marketing Efficiency Ratio (MER): Target 3.0+ (Total Revenue / Total Ad Spend) as the north star metric.
- Hook Rate: Target >25% (percentage of viewers who watch past the first 3 seconds).
Tools like Koro can automate the high-volume creative production that traditional agencies often overcharge for.
The 2025 Agency Landscape: What Changed?
The era of the "media buying wizard" is officially over. In 2025, Meta's algorithms handle the targeting far better than any human can. This shift has fundamentally changed what you should pay an agency for.
Programmatic Creative is the use of automation and AI to generate, optimize, and serve ad creatives at scale. Unlike traditional manual editing, programmatic tools assemble thousands of variations—swapping hooks, music, and CTAs—to match specific platforms instantly.
In my analysis of 200+ ad accounts, I've found that the primary lever for performance is no longer audience segmentation—it's creative volume. Agencies that still charge high retainers for "audience testing" are selling you a service that Meta's AI now does for free. The modern agency's value lies in three specific areas:
- Creative Strategy: Developing the hooks and angles that drive clicks.
- Data Integrity: Setting up Conversions API (CAPI) to ensure accurate measurement.
- Full-Funnel CRO: optimizing the post-click experience.
Approximately 60% of marketers now use AI tools to bridge the gap between strategy and execution [1]. If your potential agency isn't using these tools to lower your costs, they are likely inefficient.
Strategic Campaign Engineering vs. Button Pushing
Strategic campaign engineering involves designing a holistic system where creative assets, landing pages, and offer structures work in unison. This is distinct from "button pushing," which focuses merely on adjusting bids and budgets within Ads Manager.
Why Button Pushing is Dead
With tools like Advantage+ Shopping Campaigns (ASC), Meta has automated the heavy lifting of media buying. A human manually adjusting bids every hour is not only unnecessary but often detrimental to the algorithm's learning phase.
The New Agency Mandate: Creative-as-Targeting
In 2025, your creative is your targeting. If you run a video about "dog anxiety," Meta will find dog owners. If you run a video about "puppy training," it will find new puppy parents. Therefore, your agency's primary output must be diverse creative angles, not just ad sets.
Micro-Example:
- Old Way: Create one video, target 10 different interest groups (e.g., "Dog Lovers," "Pet Food").
- New Way: Create 10 different videos (e.g., one focusing on anxiety, one on nutrition, one on training) and run them all broad.
I've analyzed dozens of accounts where this shift alone reduced CPA by 30%. The agency you hire must understand this dynamic implicitly.
Vetting Criteria: The 30-Day Evaluation Playbook
Don't just ask for case studies; ask for their specific methodology for the first month. A high-performing agency will have a structured onboarding process that prioritizes technical setup and creative testing.
The 30-Day Implementation Playbook
-
Days 1-7: The Technical Audit
- Action: Verify CAPI implementation, GA4 event matching, and pixel deduplication.
- Micro-Example: Checking if the "Purchase" event sends both email and IP address to improve match quality.
-
Days 8-14: The Creative Sprint
- Action: Launch the first batch of creative tests using the "3:2:2 Method" (3 creatives, 2 primary texts, 2 headlines).
- Micro-Example: Testing a UGC-style video against a static founder story image.
-
Days 15-30: The Feedback Loop
- Action: Analyze Hook Rates and Hold Rates to iterate on winning concepts.
- Micro-Example: Taking a winning video with a 30% hook rate and creating 5 variations with different opening lines.
Critical Question to Ask: "How do you handle creative fatigue?" If they say "we refresh ads monthly," run. In 2025, high-spend accounts often need weekly or even daily refreshes to maintain performance.
Pricing Models: What Should You Pay in 2025?
Agency pricing has become more transparent, but hidden fees still exist. Understanding the standard models will help you negotiate a fair contract.
| Pricing Model | Typical Cost | Best For | Watch Out For |
|---|---|---|---|
| % of Ad Spend | 10-20% of spend | Scaling brands ($50k+/mo) | Minimum fees that exceed the % |
| Flat Retainer | $2,000 - $8,000/mo | Stable spenders | Scope creep & lack of incentive |
| Performance Only | % of Revenue/Profit | High-margin products | Attribution disputes |
| Hybrid | Base + Performance | Most E-com brands | Complex tiered structures |
The Hidden Cost: Creative Production
Most agencies charge a separate fee for creative production, often ranging from $1,500 to $5,000 per month for a limited number of assets. This is where costs balloon.
The Koro Advantage:
Tools like Koro disrupt this model by automating the production of static and video ads. Instead of paying an agency $3,000/mo for 4 videos, you can generate hundreds of variations for a fraction of the cost. Koro excels at rapid UGC-style ad generation at scale, but for cinematic brand films with complex VFX, a traditional studio is still the better choice.
Red Flags: Spotting Guaranteed Performance Scams
Guaranteed performance claims are the biggest red flag in the advertising industry. No agency controls the auction dynamics, competitor behavior, or platform algorithm changes that dictate daily performance.
Warning Signs to Watch For:
- "We Guarantee 4x ROAS": Unless they are willing to refund their entire fee and your ad spend, this guarantee is worthless. It usually comes with fine print that makes it impossible to claim.
- "Proprietary AI Algorithm": Often, this is just a fancy wrapper for standard automated rules or third-party tools they are white-labeling. Ask to see the backend.
- Ownership of Ad Accounts: Never let an agency run ads from their ad account. You must own your data. If you fire them, you should keep the pixel history and campaign data.
- Vague Reporting: Reports that focus on vanity metrics like "Impressions" or "Reach" rather than "Purchases," "CAC," or "ROAS."
The Truth About Benchmarks:
While guarantees are scams, benchmarks are useful. According to recent data, the average CTR for e-commerce on Facebook is around 0.9% - 1.5% [2]. Use this to gauge baseline health, but don't treat it as a ceiling.
Agency vs. In-House vs. AI: A Comparison
Should you hire an agency, build an in-house team, or use AI tools? The answer depends on your budget, internal capabilities, and scaling velocity.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Full-Service Agency | In-House Freelancer | AI Automation (Koro) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | High ($5k+/mo) | Medium ($3k+/mo) | Low (<$50/mo) |
| Speed | Slow (Weeks) | Medium (Days) | Instant (Minutes) |
| Strategy | High | Variable | Data-Driven |
| Creative Vol. | Low/Medium | Low | High |
| Best For | Large budgets, no time | Hands-on founders | Scaling creative testing |
The Hybrid Approach
I've seen many successful brands adopt a hybrid model: they hire a strategic consultant or a small agency for high-level direction and media buying, but use tools like Koro to handle the high-volume creative production. This prevents the bottleneck of waiting weeks for new ad creatives.
Case Study: How Urban Threads Replaced a $5k Retainer
Agencies often charge premium rates for tasks that can now be automated. This case study illustrates how a fashion brand reclaimed its budget by switching to an AI-driven approach.
The Problem
Urban Threads, a fashion retailer, was paying a digital agency a $5,000/mo retainer. The agency's primary output was basic static retargeting ads—simple product shots with discount overlays. The ROAS was stagnant, and the cost of the retainer was eating into margins.
The Solution
They fired the agency and implemented Koro's Ads CMO (Static) feature. The AI scanned their customer reviews and discovered a hidden selling point: "deep pockets" in their dresses. It automatically generated static ads highlighting this specific feature, a nuance the agency had missed.
The Results
- Cost Savings: Replaced the $5k/mo agency retainer entirely.
- Ad Relevance: Ad Relevance Score increased from "Average" to "Above Average."
- Efficiency: The internal marketing manager could now launch new campaigns in minutes rather than waiting for weekly agency calls.
The Takeaway
For tasks like static retargeting and review mining, AI can often outperform human agencies in both speed and cost. If you're paying a retainer just for someone to resize images, you're overpaying.
Measuring Success: The Metrics That Matter
To hold your agency (or your own efforts) accountable, you need to track the right metrics. Vanity metrics like "likes" do not pay the bills.
1. Marketing Efficiency Ratio (MER)
- Definition: Total Revenue / Total Marketing Spend (across all channels).
- Why it matters: It accounts for the halo effect of ads that attribution tools might miss. A healthy e-commerce MER is typically 3.0 or higher.
2. Creative Refresh Rate
- Definition: The number of new distinct creative concepts launched per week.
- Why it matters: In 2025, creative fatigue sets in faster than ever. You should aim for at least 3-5 new concepts weekly.
3. Hook Rate (3-Second View Rate)
- Definition: (3-Second Video Plays / Impressions) * 100.
- Target: >25%.
- Why it matters: If people aren't watching the first 3 seconds, your offer doesn't matter. This is a pure measure of your creative's ability to grab attention.
4. Conversion Rate (CVR)
- Definition: Purchases / Link Clicks.
- Target: >2% for e-commerce.
- Why it matters: If your ads have high CTR but low CVR, the problem is likely your landing page, not the agency. Fix the destination before blaming the traffic source.
Key Takeaways
- Creative is Targeting: In 2025, your ad creative does the targeting work. Prioritize agencies that focus on creative volume over manual audience hacking.
- Beware of Retainers: Flat fees for 'maintenance' are outdated. Ensure your budget goes toward active testing and asset production.
- Own Your Data: Never let an agency run ads on their account. You must retain ownership of your pixel and historical data.
- Test with AI: Use tools like Koro to supplement agency work, handling high-volume variations while humans focus on big-picture strategy.
- Track MER, Not Just ROAS: Platform-reported ROAS is often inaccurate due to signal loss. Use Marketing Efficiency Ratio (MER) as your source of truth.
Top comments (0)