DEV Community

underway
underway

Posted on Originally published at underway.life

How to make a good hook for youtube shorts, like an editor

how to make a good hook for youtube shorts: open on the single most interesting thing you said, with the point in the first word or two, your face lit and in frame, and a line that makes sense to someone who has never heard of you. you get about two or three seconds before a thumb moves on, and youtube studio counts every viewer who swipes away.

most of page one for this search is a list of formulas: ask a question, make a bold claim, show the result first. they are fine as far as they go. what they skip is the part that decides whether a formula works for you. if you talk to camera about your work, you cannot write a hook for a video you have already filmed. you can only find one in what you said, judge it, and cut it in cleanly. this guide is about those three steps, and about how underway does them for the shorts it cuts from every episode.

how to make a good hook for youtube shorts: what the first seconds need

a hook is the first two or three seconds of a short. on the shorts feed nobody chose your video: it arrived, and the viewer is deciding whether to stay. three things are working at once in those seconds.

  • what they see. a face that is lit, in frame and looking up, or the thing itself happening. a dark first frame, a blink or a head turned away loses people before a word lands.
  • what they read. a few words on screen that carry the promise. on a talking clip the honest version is the opening line itself, written large, word for word.
  • what they hear. the first sentence. it should already contain the point, not the run-up to it.

when all three say the same thing, the viewer understands in one beat. when they disagree, a nice frame over a slow sentence, or big words over a mumble, the viewer has to work, and on a feed working is the same as leaving.

the second test is cold sense. viewers meet a short with no context at all. a line like "and that's why it broke" needs the sentence before it. a line like "the signup email went to spam for three weeks and nobody told me" stands on its own. names beat pronouns, a concrete thing beats an abstract one, and a specific number beats a vague one, as long as it is a true number you actually said.

the third test is the promise. a hook tells the viewer what they are about to get. the short then has to deliver it. a hook that overpromises wins the first three seconds and loses the rest, which does the short more harm than a quieter opening that keeps its word.

how to make a good hook for youtube shorts from footage you already have

if you talk to camera about your business, your build or your week, the hook is already in the footage. the work is picking it. a method that holds up:

  • read the whole thing first. a transcript is far quicker than scrubbing a timeline. mark every line that would make sense with nothing before it.
  • for each clip you want to make, write down two to four candidate openings. they can come from anywhere in the video, not only from the start of the stretch you are clipping.
  • judge each against one question: is the point in the first word or two, and would a stranger follow it?
  • listen to how each one was said. the same sentence said with energy beats a flat reading of a slightly better sentence. pace, loudness and how much your voice moves all show on a phone screen.
  • check the picture at that moment. if it is dark, soft, or you are looking down at your notes, it cannot open the clip, however good the words are.
  • pick one, then write one line on why it won. if you cannot say why, you have not picked yet.

this is slower than reaching for a formula, and it is the only version that stays honest. you are not reading out a line you never meant. you are choosing the best true sentence you said and putting it first.

the opening frame of a youtube short: a founder looking up, the hook line written large across the top, episode 56 in the corner and made with underway at the foot
the first seconds of a real clip from episode 56 of building underway, underway's own series. the line on screen is word for word what was said, and it is the first thing a viewer sees.

hook formulas, and when they help

the formulas on page one are most useful as a way to recognise a hook in your own footage, not as lines to read out to camera. the ones that turn up most when founders and small businesses talk about their work:

what it sounds like what to check before you use it
a mistake i spent three weeks building the wrong thing that the clip goes on to say what the thing was
a result a number you hit, a customer you won, a launch that worked that the number is real and is said in the clip
a surprise something that went against what you expected that it is clear without the setup
an opinion a strong view about how your trade works that you hold it, and the clip backs it up
a question the question your customers keep asking you that the clip answers it, not only asks it

a short of thirty or forty seconds can carry one idea. if your candidate hook needs a second sentence before it makes sense, it is carrying two, and you should pick a different line.

opening on a line from later in the video

the best line is often not at the start of the stretch you want to clip. it might be the conclusion, said forty seconds in. a short can open on that line and then play the run that leads to it, as long as the opening is your own words and the run that follows is unbroken. that is a clip's privilege, not an episode's. a full episode in underway is never reordered, because it is a diary; a short is an advert for it.

the join is where it can look rough. two things help. let your voice from the run start a beat before the picture cuts to it, so the ear leads the eye. and cut on a beat of the music bed where the gap between your words allows it, never in the middle of a word to hit a beat.

the first frame and the words on screen

on a talking short the visual hook is your face. make sure the opening frame has it: lit, in frame, eyes up, not mid-blink and not mid-turn. if the light in the room was poor at that moment, choose a different line rather than fight the picture.

for text, the simplest honest choice is the opening line itself, big, for the first seconds, then captions lit word by word lower in the frame, below your chin, where they read on a phone without covering your face. plenty of people scroll with the sound off, and for them the caption is the hook.

keep the zoom calm. a punch in on every sentence is tiring to watch. change the framing only where a new thought starts, and not more than every few seconds.

a vertical youtube short with the presenter laughing on camera at the top and a recorded screen of a web app below, episode 54 in the corner
a real short cut from episode 54 of building underway: the face above, the screen he shared below, there because his words pointed at it.

a frame from a vertical short of a bearded man talking to camera in a dim room, a line at the top and one word of the captions lit in yellow near the foot
another frame from a real clip of episode 56: the captions are lit one word at a time, low in the frame, below the face.

how underway picks the hook for your shorts

underway interviews you on camera, once a day whenever suits you, and cuts your answers into a numbered episode in the order you said them. then it cuts short vertical clips from every finished episode, about one for every three minutes of episode, up to five. each clip's opening is chosen the way the method above describes:

  • every sentence arrives marked with how it was said: how loud, how fast and how much your voice moved, against your own usual voice. a lively reading beats a flat one.
  • every sentence is checked for light. a line where the picture is too dark to see your face never opens a clip.
  • for each clip, several of your own lines from anywhere in the episode are weighed as the opening against the first three seconds: is the point in the first word, and does it make sense with no context.
  • what is landing with your audience on short video this month, read in the background once a week through your connected youtube account, is weighed as well. you are never shown that read, so it can never steer what you film.
  • the best opening is kept, with a sentence on why it won.
  • before anything is made, the clips are looked over again from stills of their first seconds and every cut, and changed once if something is wrong. if that look fails for any reason, the first plan stands and the clips are still made.

the clips are ranked, the one most likely to do well first, marked best. each opens on its line, plays an unbroken run of your words with the ums, restarts and words said twice taken out, carries a quiet music bed under your voice, and ends on a card saying where the full episode is. very rarely, when a few words land harder seen than heard, they are slammed full frame for a moment before the rest plays. most clips have none.

what never changes

only your words, in the order you said them inside each run. a line you struck from the episode never comes back in a clip. the words on screen are copied from what you said. it is you, full frame, with a screen you shared shown below your face only when the clip's words point at it. podcast clips are the episode's card with the line as the headline and both voices captioned, and a guest interview's clips stack you and your guest. the episode itself is never touched.

after you post

two small things send people from a good short to the rest of your work. on youtube, set the full episode as the short's related video in youtube studio, which puts a link to it under the short. and because instagram, tiktok and shorts do not let anyone tap a link in a caption, put your page in your bio once: every clip's last card names it.

then read the number that measures a hook most directly: in youtube studio, how many people viewed a short against how many swiped away. use it to learn what kind of line holds people. just do not let it decide what you talk about next. the next episode should still be about what happened, and the hook should still be found in it, not written for it.

how long should a youtube shorts hook be?

the first two or three seconds, usually one sentence. if it needs a second sentence to make sense, pick a different line.

should i write my hook before filming?

you can plan the subject, but a line written to camera usually sounds written. a better route is a good question: answer it properly and the hook is usually somewhere in the answer. underway's interview asks those questions out loud.

can the hook come from later in the video?

yes, for a short. open on the line, then play the run it belongs to. keep it your own words and keep the run unbroken.

why did my clip not open on the line i expected?

underway weighed it against the others. it may have been said with less life, needed the line before it to make sense, or been filmed too dark to see your face.

will my existing clips change?

no. clips already made stay as they are. find clips again on an episode's shorts tab makes a fresh set.

the rest of the job, from one long video to a set of shorts: turn a long video into shorts.

what youtube shows before anyone presses play: add a thumbnail to youtube shorts.


Originally published at https://underway.life/how-to-make-a-good-hook-for-youtube-shorts

Top comments (0)